From collection Creating Acadia National Park: The George B. Dorr Research Archive of Ronald H. Epp

Page 1
Search
results in pages
Metadata
Schoodic Peninsula
Schoodic Periusula
Acadia History
SCHOODIC'S JOHN GODFREY MOORE
Allan Smallidge
ad John Godfrey Moore not died pre-
mon schools, and spent one year at nearby
the deal. Moore was subsequently elected to
H
maturely at age fifty-one, the wildly
Cherryfield Academy. When he was 18, he
the Western Union board of directors.
beautiful Schoodic Point might be a
went to New York and entered into employ-
After living some years abroad, Moore
very different place today. As it happened, after
ment as a clerk in the lumber dealership of
returned to New York as the head of the bro-
Moore's death his heirs began spending their
Thomas Mahew and Wilson Godfrey, his
kerage firm Moore and Schley, also acquiring
time away from their summer places in Winter
uncle. At age 21, Moore started his own lum-
large interests in Chase Manhattan Bank and
Harbor and it was not until 1922, some twen-
ber business and prospered almost immedi-
several railroads. After the panic of 1893, he
ty years after his death, that George Dorr was
ately. In company with a partner named John
invested $25,000 of his own money in a case
able to make arrangements to acquire
Evans, he executed several important con-
to defeat a new federal income tax law. The
Schoodic for the park. By then Moore's some-
tracts with the War Department, including
Supreme Court ruled in his favor and the
what younger second wife, Louise, had remar-
piers and breakwaters at Buffalo, New York,
law was defeated, at least for the time being.
ried and Moore's daughters were living in
and Cleveland, Ohio, as well as dredging
All during his career, he maintained his
England, one married to Viscount Lee and the
projects along the Delaware River.
interest in and loyalty to the rural section of
other, a spinster, living near her sister. The
In 1880, he and Evans went into the fast-
Maine from which he sprang. He became
contact between Dorr and Louise Leeds was
developing telegraph business, founding
involved in the plan to develop Grindstone
a casual one, made while both were having
the Mutual Union Telegraph Company and
Neck in Winter Harbor and built himself one
supper at the Jordan Pond House, but the
constructing lines to rival Western Union.
of the largest cottages there, which he called
result was that Dorr was able to set the wheels
Their intentions were to lease their lines to
"Far From the Wolf." He purchased hundreds
in motion for the eventual land acquisition.
businesses by day and to newspapers by
of acres of forest and islands in the vicinity,
At the time of his death, however, Moore
night. Before all their plans could be real-
including Schoodic Point. He built Schoodic
had vastly different plans for Schoodic Point.
ized Evans died and Moore, as the new pres-
Drive, the first carriage road on the point,
John Godfrey Moore came from modest
ident, led the company into one of the biggest
which wound from his newly-built bridge at
beginnings. He was born in Steuben, Maine,
competitive wars in the history of telegraphy.
Frazer Creek, along the bold, rocky shores to
the son of Captain Henry D. and Maria
The outcome was that Western Union was
the salt ponds and Devil's Anvil. His road also
(Godfrey) Moore. The young Moore took
forced to lease Mutual Union lines. Moore
climbed to the summit of Schoodic Head, a
whatever schooling he had at the local com-
and his associates realized vast profits from
favorite spot, reputedly, because from there
Picnic party on Schoodic Head, July 1923.
Summer 2005
Friends of Acadia Journal
he could see all the way to his native Steuben
placed a bronze tablet in his memory at the
ALLAN SMALLIDGE is a native of Winter
and beyond. He had plans to build a grand
overlook on Big Moose Island. Also in his
Harbor and a graduate of the University of
hotel at the summit, and supposedly
honor, in 1937 the name of the road which
Maine. After a career teaching high school
had ideas for the further development of
runs from the village south to the bridge at
English both in Maine and in Massachusetts
the rest of Schoodic. He died, however, before
Frazer's Creek was officially, albeit belatedly,
public schools, he returned to Winter Harbor
these plans could be brought to fruition.
changed by the people of Winter Harbor from
to serve as Town Manager for fourteen years,
Apparently his heirs were not as enamored
Schoodic Street to the Moore Road.
until retiring in 1998.
of the area as he was, although his daughter
Faith did maintain a summer home on
Grindstone for several years afterward.
FORESIGHT E GENEROSITY
The day after Moore's death, an article
appeared in the Bar Harbor Record quoting
a previous interview with him concerning his
acquisition of Schoodic Point and the islands
and of the pleasure he realized from building
the first substantial road on the point. He stat-
ed that he had acquired the land because of
its beauty, noting that there was nothing he
admired more than a mountain, "especially
when an ocean goes with it." Also, he
explained, he had enjoyed the experience of
Yankee trading with the previous land own-
ers, and he thought that it would be a good
investment considering what was being
developed in Bar Harbor at the time. The
road, he said, was built for his own pleasure
and convenience, but also as an object lesson
in economy for the local authorities. He felt
that they could repeat his successes in the
public roads all over the area. Moore said,
"[The road] is nine miles long and I enjoyed
every foot of it It did me and my family
as much good as a trip to Europe and didn't
cost any more. Besides, it gave employment
Schoodic Point
to a large number of people who need the
ESTATE PLANNING
money." While it may have seemed arrogant
of him to assume that he could teach the
Preserving and protecting those things that we all hold dear - our quality of
locals how to build roads, any hard feelings
life, a distinctive heritage, and the integrity of Mount Desert Island's
the statement may have provoked was prob-
natural wonders is a wise investment. You can help protect Acadia forever.
ably defused with his sincere efforts to cre-
It's simple. Add only one of the following sentences to your will, or a codicil:
ate jobs and to aid the local economy.
After Moore died on June 27, 1899, con-
1. I hereby give
% of my residuary estate to Friends of
current services were held in New York City
Acadia, Inc., a Maine charitable corporation, P.O. Box 45,
and at St. Christopher's-by-the-Sea in Winter
Bar Harbor, Maine 04609, for its charitable purposes.
Harbor. Bedford Tracy, a young Winter Harbor
attorney who was a local associate of Moore's,
2. 1 hereby bequeath $
to Friends of Acadia, Inc.,
elaborately eulogized him at the Grindstone
a Maine charitable corporation, P.O. Box 45, Bar Harbor, Maine
service and concluded with the words, "The
04609, for its charitable purposes.
fragrance of his acts of kindness perfumes
his sepulcher, and he must live on, embalmed
3. I hereby devise the following property to Friends of Acadia, Inc.,
by our love and garlanded with our affec-
a Maine charitable corporation, P.O. Box 45, Bar Harbor, Maine
04609, for its charitable purposes: [legal description of property].
tion. The cold marble bears in mockery many
a name forgotten but for the letters chiseled
on its icy slab. It cannot be SO with the name
of John G. Moore, which is chiseled on the
For more information, contact Lisa Horsch at 1-800-625-0321,
tablets of too many hearts to need the aid of
email her at lisahorsch@friendsofacadia.org, or visit our
marble or bronze to perpetuate it."
website at www.friendsofacadia.org
Nevertheless, Acadia National Park has
Friends of Acadia Journal
Summer 2005
7
ADDRESS ONLY
THE DIRECTOR, NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
WASHINGTON. D. c.
UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
WASHINGTON
October 10, 1928.
Personal and Private.
Dear Mr. Rockefeller:
x
Congressman Cramton, with his wife, visited the Lafayette National
Park and the immediately surrounding areas on September 23rd and 24th last.
I arrived the 22d and stayed till the 26th, being in conference with Bureau
of Public Roads executives on the last day.
Mr. Cramton was tremendously impressed with the park, especially the
work done on the motor road and horse roads and was sorry he could not
stay longer. Through your kindness, Mr. Ralston took us over the Sargent
Mountain drive, and some of the carriage roads on your place. Mr. Cramton
said that the view from the Sargent Mountain road is one of the most in-
spiring he had ever seen. In fact I believe it was this that inspired
him to plan ahead for Lafayette National Park along larger lines as he
later did.
GBD.
He was told by Mr.Dorr of the various offers of land at verious points
outside the island proper, such as Schoodic Head, and gave it very definite-
ly as his opinion that the Lafayette National Park act, which limits ac-
quisition of lands for the park to the island, should be amended so as
to save, while they still can be saved, such islands as the Porcupines,
Schoodic and other important headlands, - in fact, anything that would
protect the splendid views from the areas within the park and the fine
estates on the island. Bills will therefore be introduced in the coming
Congress to provide for such enlargement. Mr. Dorr is already working on
this with Maine representatives.
I had the opportunity very thoroughly to go into some of our adminis-
trative problems with Mr. Cramton. As a result additional funds will be
Agency
provided for a position of Associate Superintendent who is to take all
administrative burdens off the shoulders of Superintendent Dorr, Mr. Dorr
CRD
to continue as Superintendent with his sole duty the acquisition of lands
for the enlargement of the park; to effect this a special provision will
be inserted excepting him from the provisions of the Federal Retirement
Act. After Mr. Cramton's departure, I discussed this whole situation with
Mr. Dorr, who was much pleased, and thoroughly in sympathy with the plans.
I think this will work out very nicely, despite a few complications which
I will have to straighten out.
Mr. Cramton was very sorry to have missed you, since, particularly
after going over some of the roads and seeing some of the truly remarkable
roadside work that is being done, he desired to express to you personally
his sincere appreciation of your work.
It occurred to me that you would like to have thus briefly the above
few highlights, which is my reason for writing.
Faithfully,
Mr. John D. Rockefeller, Jr.,
26 Broadway,
New York City.
Northeast Harbor, Me.,
14 September 1923
My dear Dorr:
Ellist
Before I built a house in 1881 near Northeast
1873
Harbor, I camped on Calf Island, Frenchman's Bay, for
eight years, and then became very familiar with the shores
of the Bay and all its passages and inlets which were safe
for 2 good-sized sailing yacht which drew five feet and a
half. I then made the acquaintance of Schoodic Eoad and
all the approaches to it by land and water. During these
years I repeatedly climbed Schoodic Head, and enjoyed the
wonderful prospects northeasterly by Petit Manan and beyond
towards Grand Nanan, southwesterly tcwards Baker's Island,
the Duck Islands, and Iale am Esut, and due vest to the
high hills of Mount Desert Island just across the bay.
These prospects are unique. They are far the finest on
the Atlantic Coast of the United States; and therefore
the Head itself should be preserved in all its own beauty
of geologic structure and forest decoration for the enjoy-
ment of future generations.
This conservation can be best made sure by adding
the Schoodic Peninsula to the Lafayette National Park now
established on Mount Desert Island. It will then come
under the scientific management of the National Pale Sereice.
Sinf your
Chall W.Eliat.
for
To
file
BY
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
DEC 26 Rec'd
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
J.
D.
R.,
LAFAYETTE NATIONAL PARK
REMARKS
BAR HARBOR, MAINE
OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT
December 22, 1923.
Dear Mr. Rockefeller:
I sent off last night to Washington the
deeds for an exceedingly interesting tract of land given
by Mrs. John Innes Kane of New York in memory of her
sister, Mrs. Bridgham. It includes, in its entirety, the
whole drainage basin of Lake Wood, a picturesque little
lake not visible from any public road which lies north
of that from Hull's Cove to the Bridge, and west of
the Breakneck Road. It is wholly surrounded by woods,
largely deciduous, which turn wonderful colors in the
fall, with some fine old pines upon a rocky height above.
A little lakelet, called Fawn Pond, sunk deep in woods,
which with its surroundings was given to the Bar Harbor
Village Improvement Society some twenty years ago by
Mr. Charles T. How, drains into it, and the land he gave
joins on to this, making an unbroken reservation. The
tract which Mrs. Kane has given reaches eastward far
beyond the lake to meet the bridle path built by the
town of Bar Harbor to the west of the Breakneck Road in
continuation of the one from Witch Hole pond, and an old
woodroad branching off from this and running through the
tract skirts close beside the lake.
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
LAFAYETTE NATIONAL PARK
BAR HARBOR, MAINE
OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT
3.
horse or on foot, to return to a forest wilderness as the
woods grow up on the cut-over lands. This gift of
Mrs. Kane then would form the northern portion of its
western bound.
Another tract that I have recently secured is
I
the Ella C. White land I told you of upon the Bluffs, and
reaching below them to the Bay across the Bar Harbor -
Hull's Cove road. Two nephews of Miss White, a visitor
of the early days, inherited it. Both died, leaving
widows who have both married since. One of these,
coming to Bar Harbor, offered me her undivided half-interest
in the tract; the deeds for it were prepared and signed
this fall. In returning them, the giver offered to use
her influence to get the other undivided interest given
also if I would write the owner of our work and plans.
This I did and recently this, too, was given, the deed
being returned to me through Mr. Richard Aldrich of Providence,
husband of the owner, who is a member of Congress.
It is really a noble tract in its bold
outlook on the Bay and one on which the real estate agents
here quoted to me from their books, when I first took
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
LAFAYETTE NATIONAL PARK
BAR HARBOR. MAINE
OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT
4.
the matter of the Bluff lands up, a price of twenty thousand
dollars. Half this probably would represent fair value
now, which leaves it still a handsome gift.
Another tract which I seem now in a fair way to
get, not for the Park but for the Public Reservations whose
field lies wider, is that of Schoodic Head and Point,
the bold and wooded terminus of the long peninsula which
forms the eastern shore of Frenchman's Bay. This is
a tract of some two thousand acres with a road to its summit
commanding a magnificent view, eastward up the Bay of Fundy
and westward across Frenchman's Bay to the Island mountains.
The tract was one gathered together in the course of years
by Mr. John G. Moore, a native of the region who returned
to it after a successful business life elswhere and built
up, out of interest in the territory as his native land,
the summer colony at Grindstone Neck and formed this
reservation out of many ownerships as a parkland for it,
building the road to the summit of the Head before he
died. This, with other property, on his death, passed
in undivided thirds to a widow and to two daughters by an
earlier marriage. The death last winter of t he widow
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
LAFAYETTE NATIONAL PARK
BAR HARBOR, MAINE
OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT
5.
brought up the question of the ultimate disposition of the
land and I am now in correspondence with Mr. Moore's daughter,
Lady Lee of Fareham, who married an English diplomat met
at Washington, and hone to get from her and her sister,
who lives with her in England, the gift of the whole tract,
made in memory of their father. Obtained, it should make
a splendid longer ride from the Island for motorists and
content them in leaving uninvaded areas within the Park
desirable to keep secluded.
The tract on Eagle Lake still held by the water
company I expect to get transferred to the Park on a
similar basis as the rest before next summer. I had the
matter agreed upon with the executive committee but the
death of Mr. Cuyler and illness of Mr. Ogden, with a new
member on the board replacing Mr. Cuyler, made it seem
advisable to postpone the matter till I could make sure
of my ground. It was the last land purchased by the
water company and represents considerable expenditure, so
I need to show a strong case, which I have, to insure the
transfer. It covers a mile of shore.
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
LAFAYETTE NATIONAL PARK
BAR HARBOR, MAINE
OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT
6.
The MacFarland pasture with its blocking cattle-
way to the lake front it may be necessary to get by
condemnation. It ought not to exist as pasture, draining
directly down into the lake near the ice and water intakes
through a wet-weather streamlet and forming itself a
collecting basin, over-flowing in wet seasons. I
secured for the Public Reservations condemnation rights
for the protection of the water supply, the Water Company
having previously tried and failed to get them, but in
securing the whole basin of the lake but this, with the
check upon unreasonable prices the condemnation rights
in the background gave, I never had to use it, and if
MacFarland realizes that the power exists it may not be
necessary now. The power can only be used upon approval
of the State board of health.
I have been taking advantage of the leafless con-
dition of the woods, mild weather and bare ground to study
out plans for the ultimate completion of the bridle path and
horse-road system which have been gradually forming in my
mind. I want at least to plan for the extension of the
system from the central to the eastern section by leading
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
LAFAYETTE NATIONAL PARK
BAR HARBOR, MAINE
OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT
7.
it around the mass of Green and Dry Mountains, as on the
western side it will pass around that of Jordan and Sargent.
But the construction will be relatively simple, with little
necessary rock-work, old roadways to utilize, and good
gravelly soil over a great portion of the way.
What I have in mind, in part made possible by the
Traveli purchase of last winter, is to unite with you,
representing the Park and owners of the land, to ask the
Town of Mount Desert at its annual meeting to relinquish
whatever rights it may possess by usage or otherwise in the
Boyd Road from the Wildwood Farm Road junction north, and
on this being done, to use it in either direction, north and
south, from the summit of its rise -- reached by the road
you plan through the Triad - Day Mountain pass or by the
Triad - Pemetic pass. The Boyd Road in that section is
beautiful in summer with its overshadowing hardwood
trees, and would introduce an oldtime element into the
driving road system which it would take years to get in
building new, and going south it could be led to the eastern
side of the valley to avoid connection with the southern
portion of the Boyd Road, continued by the Wildwood Farm
Road; then, kept gradually mounting to cross the descending
southern ridge of Green Mountain wherever survey might show
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
LAFAYETTE NATIONAL PARK
BAR HARBOR, MAINE
OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT
8.
as best, obtaining in crossing it a splendid ocean view.
Then descending again on the eastern side to cross the
valley of the brook that comes down from between Green Mountain
and Dry Mountain, and ascending its low eastern ridge to
continue through the Eliot woods at the bottom of the
valley between Dry and Newport Mountains, skirting the
side of the Tarn, the little sheet of water in the gorge,
without crossing or entering the public road, and down
its outlet valley to the Great Meadow, crossing it northward
to connect with the survey that Mr. Simpson made when we were
first studying the outlet of the motor road. His survey,
rising from the present motor road, led above an old quarry
with a superb view over Frenchman's Bay and then descended
gradually where it crossed the brook, turned and descending
still, turned eastward finally to skirt the golf links opposite
the Building of Arts, and the wooded eastern base of Kebo
mountai - to the Great Meadow.
The Martin Roberts road would be utilized from the
foot of Bubble Pond to where he built his camp upon the shore
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
LAFAYETTE NATIONAL PARK
BAR HARBOR, MAINE
OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT
9.
of Eagle Lake whence an excellent old wood road mounts to
a point easily connected with the former Beaton farm land
across which it could be led in easy grade to cross the
Park motor road at right angles on the level just north
of the big stone culvert and in the open where it would
be under observation and could be kept easily to right
use. After crossing the motor road it would follow the
line of the old Beaton haul-road till it should intersect
Mr. Simpson's survey.
The only land necessary to secure for carrying
this out beyond what Mr. Lynam is now at world upon by
Otter Creek and what I hold myself is the Kebo Spring
property of fifty acres at the head of the Great
Meadow, where it blocks the way, and portions of the
Roberts and the Rodick Realty lands on the north ridge
of Green Mountain, above the constructed section of the
Park motor road, and down its rugged eastern slope to
Kebo brook.
The eastern side of Kebo brook we have, and
thence on, bordering the Golf Links on the way, till
blocked by the Kebo Spring land from the Meadow.
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
NATIONAL PARK SERVICE
LAFAYETTE NATIONAL PARK
BAR HARBOR, MAINE
OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT
10.
Such a system would not once cross a public
way; it would have great variety and ,interest; and if the
necessary land should be secured, I believe there would
be no difficulty nor long postponement in getting
the Government to build it as at least a horseback
way.
The position of the whole bridle path and
driving system as a unique and special institution of the
Park and permanent feature would be greatly strengthened
if I were able to show such a completed plan for the
whole body of the Park, to the westward of Somes Sound,
coming within reach of all important residential sections
and resort communities. The building of it would be
secondary to the possibility of showing it as a connected
scheme.
Believe me, with best wishes of this
Christmas season and for the coming year,
Sincerely yours,
Gunge B. DoH
Paul 6. Favour,In (1968)
JUSTIFICATION FOR OFFSHORE ISLANDS
Acadia National Park
&
Acadia National rark is a coastal National Park. Its
paramount values are those associated with the sea - its
seascape scenery, its marine plants and animals, and its
marine history. Acadia is basically an archipelago park,
for between and near its major segments (Mount Desert Island,
Schoodic Peninsula and Isle au Haut), be some 250 smaller
islands and islets.
file
These offshore islands are an inseparable part of the
Acadia scene. Collectively, for the most part unoccupied,
they represent Acadia's wilderness along with Isle au Haut.
Currently, a very few of these islands form a part of the
park. It is here proposed that the 73 offshore islands
shown on this Boundary Plan be acquired for addition to
the park.
The selection of these 73 islands is based upon first hand
knowledge of them by one or more members of the park staff.
Each has been selected because of its outstanding, special,
or above average contribution to the total picture.
Although there are varying specific reasons for choosing
these 73, all may be considered as especially desirable
for National Park status in terms of preservation of the
natural scene, and especially including their shorelines
and shore line vegetation.
Of the 73 currently selected offshore islands, only 16
have a summer camp or other dwelling on them.
There follows in more detail additional justification data
for ac quisition of the 73 selected offshore islands, either
individually or by groups:
Schoodic area
Schoodic Island supports the largest single gull colony
in the Acadia archipelago; it also has nesting guillemots,
and from time to time, bald eagles. Turtle, Mark, Ned,
Spectacle, Heron, and off the east side, Rolling, are all
part of the Schoodic scene and ought to be preserved in
their status quo. Turtle Island was recently purchased
by The Nature Conservancy to prevent its being completely
logged off by a pulp company. It will no doubt eventually
be donated to the park.
Middle Frenchman Bay
The route of the very popular Naturalist Sea Cruise which
has been conducted by the park since 1932 passes closely
by Ironbound, Jordan, Long Porcupine, The Hop, Rum Key,
Burnt Porcupine, and Thrumcap Islands. These are all
outstandingly scenic islands and all are prominent in the
view from Cadillac Mountain. Ironbound is unique in that
it has the highest perpendicular cliffs in the whole park
area, and also in that it has the oldest (200+ years)
virgin spruce stand known along the Maine coast. It is
owned by a conservation-minded family. Long Porcupine
has steep cliffs, nesting guillemots, a heron colony,
and a natural bridge. Burnt Porcupine has an intermit-
tently occupied eagle nest.
Upper Frenchman Bay
Calf Island is the site of the most extensive and most
valuable (i.e., undisturbed) Indian shell heap within
the park environs.
Cranberry Islands
Baker Island is one of the richest in scenic and natural
history values of all of Acadia's offshore islands. It
has superb views of the Mount Desert mountains, rare plants
and a south shore seawall of huge granite blocks. More
than half the island is now owned by the park. There
remains the eastern side to be secured. Baker Island is
the objective of a popular Naturalist-conducted combination
cruise and nature walk.
Duck Islands
Great Duck and Little Duck are the only known nesting sites
in Acadia for Leach's petrels and blackpoll warblers. Besides
having large sea bird colonies (gulls, guillemots, and some
eiders), the Ducks have several species of rare arctic
plants. Little Duck is owned by the National Audubon
Society. Both islands offer splendid views of Mount Desert
Island's mountains.
2
Gott Islands
Little Gott, Placentia, Black, and Little Black have high,
steep, richly colored pink granite shorelines and dense
forest growths of white spruce. All are very high in
aesthetic value. Placentia has recently had an active bald
eagle's nest at its western end. This island is owned by
a conservation-minded couple who might be persuaded to will
the island to the park.
Long Island (Frenchboro) group
While the northern portion of (outer) Long Island is the
site of the sparsely populated village of Frenchboro, the
southern half is unoccupied and is now in Rockefeller
ownership. The southern exposed shore is extremely rugged
pink granite, and because of its exposure to cold sea winds,
is the site of a northern flora.
The two Green Islands and John Island have significant sea
bird colonies. The two Sister Islands which lie directly
along the outer route between Mount Desert Island and
Isle au Haut are outstanding aesthetically.
Opeechee Island group
Opeechee, Pond, Black, Sheep, and Johns Islands form a group
which is important both biologically and recreationally.
At low tide they are either connected by a very extensive
exposed intertidal zone area or separated by very shallow
water, thus offering excellent opportunity for intertidal
zone research and interpretation. Large numbers of black
ducks congregate in the fall in the shallow basin between
Opeechee and Sheep while in summer many seals are to be
seen in this basin. Black Island has a beautiful pink sand
beach, unique in the Acadia archipelago, on its southern
shore, and Pond Island has a sizeable sand beach along its
north shore, as well as a smaller sand beach and nearby
extensive Indian shell heap along its south shore. Tiny
Lamp Island has the appearance of a mushroom, formed by
the sea erosion of a glacial till cap. Eagle Island is a
scenic jewel with a steep granite shoreline. Ship and
Trumpet are low treeless islands with sizeable gull and
cormorant colonies. Buckles and Orono Islands which lie
along the direct inner route between Mount Desert Island and
Isle au Haut, are high in aesthetic value. Buckles and Orono
are Rockefeller-owned.
3
Marshall Island group
Although Marshall Island more or less recently has been
pulped and burned over, it has in its Sand Cove the finest
sand beach in the whole of the Acadia archipelago. Along
its west shore is another excellent but smaller sand beach.
Along with its attractive satellite island, Ringtown,
Marshall Island would be an ideal site for camping, picnick-
ing, and swimming. It is presently owned by a Camden, Maine
fisherman who, we understand, is chiefly interested in main-
taining his herring fishing rights in Sand Cove. Mason
Ledge is a sea bird colony site.
Isle au Haut area
Eastern Ear and Western Ear are two very striking high-
cliffed islands lying immediately off Eastern Head and
western Head which are the two park-owned southern extremities
of Isle au Haut. Deer frequent both Ears. Western Ear is
connected to Western Head at low tide by a gravel bar. 30th
Little Spoon and Great Spoon Island are treeless islands
where both great black-backed - and herring gulls, and possibly
eiders, nest. Great Spoon also has very large and conspicuous
examples of black basaltic dikes along its western and southern
granite shorelines.
Merchant Row archipelago
Nowhere else along the entire Maine coast is there another
grouping of small islands quite like this one which lies
between Isle au Haut and Stonington on Deer Isle. Alto-
gether some 50 islands make up this closely-knit archipelago.
A leisurely cruise among them with perhaps a landing on and
exploration of one of them is one of the most memorable
experiences the Acadia region has to offer. A total of 27
of these small islands is here proposed for park acquisition.
These are Pell, Mouse, Wheat, 3ills, Wreck, McGlathery,
Little McGlathery, Round, Gooseborry, No Mans, Saddleback,
Enchanted, Phoebe, Shingle, Millet, Spruce, Ram, Buckle,
two Coombs, two Coot, Camp, Hells Half Acre, Devil, Eastern
Mark, and Southern Mark Islands. Each of these except
4
Southern Mark is an out and out scenic gem with glacially
rounded granite shorelines and dark blue-green crowns of
spruce. Southern Mark is a treeless gull breeding island.
All are unoccupied except Levil, Saddleback, and Shingle
which have camps on them. Shingle is Rockefeller-owned.
McGlathery is owned by a small group of conservationists,
one of whom has indicated that McGlathery would be donated
to the park if other nearby islands were also to become
park-owned. With its variable shoreline, Camp would iend
itself ideally to interpretive forays.
Further justification Master Plan data may be found on the
Visitor Use and Interpretation Plan (proposed sea cruise
routes) and the several Natural History Base Maps (location
of significant species).
There follows a table in which several significant character-
istics of these 73 selected islands have been indicated.
Some of these characteristics are shown in the appended
photographs.
Pane 4 Favour.
Paul G. Favour, Jr.
Chief Park Naturalist
October 16, 1968
5
DRAFT
ACADIA NATIONAL PARK
BAR HARBOR, MAINE
FINDING AID FOR
U.S. NAVAL SECURITY GROUP ACTIVITY
WINTER HARBOR RECORDS, 1915-2002
CATALOG NUMBER: ACAD 33731
FLEET
SUPPORT
SINCE
1935
WINTER
PREPARED BY
VICTORIA KALEMARIS ANDRILENAS
ELIZABETH S. BANKS
TERI A. DEYOUNG
DAVID J. VECCHIOLI
NORTHEAST MUSEUM SERVICES CENTER
September 2007
Collection Description
NSGA Winter Harbor Records-15
O. Historical Records
1915-1984
1. Naval Communications at Otter Cliffs and Seawall, 1917-1984
The Naval Radio Station at Otter Cliffs, ME opened in 1918 and closed in 1935 when
the Navy moved operations to Winter Harbor, ME. Includes World War I era
correspondence, memorabilia and later recollections from veterans stationed at NBD
Otter Cliffs, the Navy's precursor to US NSGA-WH and material collected by COs
about the Navy's early radio efforts in Down East Maine. 15 It is organized
alphabetically by the veterans' surnames. In some cases material, primarily
photographs could not be linked to a particular veteran. Items from unidentified
sources are filed at the end of the sub-sub-series. Included in this sub-sub-series are
World War I era photographs, copies of military citations and other ephemera
donated by Navy veterans from that era. The correspondence, research and
reminiscences are primarily from the 1960s and 1970s. It also includes programs and
photographs from the veterans' reunions in 1961 and 1965.
Of particular interest are correspondence and memoirs from 1917 to 1920 written by
Alessandro Fabbri, first commander of Naval Radio Station, Otter Cliffs. Three
veterans donated extensive material. Harold W. Castner (1888-?), Charles B. (&
Emily) Ellsworth, and Herbert C. Hovenden each realized the significance of the
station's role in World War I and radio communication advancements and wanted to
document the history of Naval Radio Station Otter Cliffs. Castner was Fabbri's
confidential aid and after Fabbri's death had access to his personal papers, a resource
he used extensively in writing a history of Otter Cliffs. However, his hero-worship of
Fabbri made his history and memoirs less comprehensive. Hovenden organized
veterans' reunions and spear-headed an effort in the late 1970s by several veterans,
including Raymond Cole, Frederick "Hank" Grindle, Carl E. Herr and Raymond
McCrae, to write a more objective history of their work at Otter Cliffs. The sub-sub-
series also includes correspondence between U.S. NSGA-WH COs (primarily CDR
T.F. Hahn, 1966-1968) and various veterans. The base held a 50th anniversary
commemorating Naval Radio Communications in Down East Maine in 1967 and the
CO at that time (CDR Hahn) was very interested in having veterans attend the
anniversary gathering the Navy organized. The commander's interest inspired
additional veterans to donate materials from their years of service. Hahn also
contacted veterans and their widows requesting biographical information with a stated
interest in their time with the Navy and their work in radio communication.
2. Early years of Naval Communications at Winter Harbor, 1931-1982
includes photographs, reports, maps, and correspondence documenting the planning,
construction, and improvements to the Schoodic Base and Corea Operations Site, as
well as correspondence with former COs and research gathered by various COs to
document the early history of the Naval base at Winter Harbor, ME.
15
There is a link between these materials and some materials in the Public Affairs Records series. The 1961
Dedication of Fabbri Hall was coordinated by the Public Affairs Office but the veterans lobbied the Navy to name
the building after Fabbri. The Public Affairs Office also organized the 50th Anniversary in 1967 but the CO made
the decision to include veterans in the celebration.
3.
NSGA Winter Harbor Records - 24
Historical Note
Chronology
The timeline below is an overview of major events and projects at U.S. Naval Station Otter
Cliffs, ME, the U.S. Naval Security Group Activity, Winter Harbor, ME and NPS projects
conducted at those two sites between 1916 and 2002 and provides a framework for
understanding the arrangement of the records sited in this finding aid.
1914: World War I begins in Europe
1916: National Park Service created
Presidential Proclamation establishes Sieur de Monts National Monument on Mount
Desert Island, ME
1917: United States enters World War I
Private citizen Alessandro Fabbri offers his radio station on Mount Desert Island, ME to
the U.S. Navy in exchange for a naval commission. U.S. Navy accepts Fabbri's offer and
Ensign Fabbri is put in charge of the station.
1918: Seawall transmitter set up in Manset, Mount Desert Island, ME;
October 6th Otter Cliffs site intercepts first message from Kaiser Wilhelm to President
Wilson concerning an armistice
1919: Fabbri requests release from active duty.
40 Stat 1778 Establishes Lafayette National Park from Sieur de Monts National
Monument
1920: Lt. Alessandro Fabbri awarded the Navy Cross for "exceptionally meritorious service in
a duty of great responsibility in the development of the radio receiving station at Otter
Cliffs, Maine and the small receiving station at Sea Wall
until at the end of the War, it
was the most important and the most efficient station in the world."
1929: 45 Stat 1803 Lafayette National Park name changed to Acadia National Park
1930: 46 Stat 377 Navy transferred Seawall and 233 acres to Acadia National Park
1932: NPS and Navy agree on Ocean Drive extension. Schoodic Point on Big Moose Island
chosen as new naval communications site
1934: Otter Cliffs communication site dismantled.
Seawall site transferred to Coast Guard
The following buildings were completed: powerhouse, navigational D/F shack, the pump
house, the transmitter house and the Apartment Building (Rockefeller Building) at
Schoodic Point.
25
Much of the information here was taken from the 2002 Base closure book.
Historical Note
NSGA Winter Harbor Records- 25
4.
1935: 49 Stat 795 Navy transferred Otter Cliffs radio station to Acadia National Park and
Acadia NP transferred a new radio site at Schoodic to the Navy
28 February U.S. Naval Radio Station (NRS) Winter Harbor was officially placed in
commission.
1939: Hitler invades Poland.
France and the United Kingdom declare war on Germany
1941: Japan bombs Pearl Harbor.
United States enters war.
1942-1989 Period of growth for base as result of WW II, Korean, Vietnam and Cold War
1942-1943:
Major expansion at the base
Building 10 new administrative offices, a mess and quarters added
Building 3 doubled in size
1944: D-Day
1945: Japan surrenders
Post WWII
1947: Navy acquires 151.86 acres from Acadia National Park
Salt water pump house, hose houses, fire protection system, coaxial cable vault in Bldg. 3
1950: Name of station changed to U.S. Naval Security Group Department, U.S. Naval Radio
Station
1951: Navy acquires 469 acres of land at Corea, ME and Direction Finding facility is moved
there from Seawall in Manset, ME.
1952: Building 39 built to provide new communications and terminal equipment
1955: Bldg, 45 Generator Bldg. erected
1957: Twenty family housing units built in the village of Winter Harbor
1958: Name changed to Naval Security Group Activity Winter Harbor
1959: First military housing (Harbor View) opened in Winter Harbor, ME.
1961: Fabbri Hall, a new enlisted barracks, dedicated.
Otter Cliffs veterans hold reunion in Bar Harbor, ME.
1962: Antennae array and Building 85 completed at Corea site
Historical Note
NSGA Winter Harbor Records- 27
History and Significance of U. S. Naval Security Group Activity Winter Harbor, 1917-2002
26
by Jannelle Warren-Findley, PhD., Arizona State University, Public History Department
INTRODUCTION
The U.S. Navy and the U.S. National Park Service in Acadia National Park, Maine, have
intertwined histories for most of the twentieth century. One year after Congress authorized the
first national park on the East Coast of the United States in 1916, the Navy established a
presence inside the park. During World War I, the Navy's lead role in radio communications led
it to acquire a radio station built by a wealthy amateur radio enthusiast at Otter Cliffs and an
additional site at Seawall on Mount Desert Island, Maine. The Navy found the site to be
extremely valuable because of its physical qualities for transmitting and receiving radio signals
and continued to use the site after the war. Eventually, however, John D. Rockefeller, Jr., the
park's primary patron, wished to use the Navy station property for the extension of the park loop
road. Through a series of negotiations, the Navy base eventually relocated to Big Moose Island
on the Schoodic Peninsula, also a part of Acadia National Park. The Schoodic installation thus
became one of the few navy bases placed for its entire working life surrounded by a national
park. This was, in fact, a spy base within a park.
Eventually known as Naval Security Group Activity Winter Harbor, the base served as a
communications installation for the next sixty four years, but its mission was affected by the
terms of the original agreement, under which Acadia National Park's administration had the right
to approve or reject all new construction and major changes to any of the Navy's buildings or
27
structures. In reality, however, the National Park Service rarely exercised its authority in these
matters. During World War II, the mission of the base was to act as part of a larger network that
communicated with Navy ships, submarines, airplanes and shore installations. The navy base
underwent a major expansion of building facilities and antenna installations to aid in the war
effort.
Many bases were decommissioned after the end of World War II. If they were needed for the
Cold War period (1945 to 1989)28 they often had to be reopened and staffed. But no such
26
First appeared as History and Significance section of U.S. Department of the Interior, National Park Service,
Northeast Museum Services Center, Acadia National Park (U.S. Naval Security Group Winter Harbor) Collection
Management Plan, pp 1-21, 2002.
27
An Act To authorize the transfer of the Otter Cliffs Radio Station on Mount Desert Island in the State of Maine as
an addition to the Acadia National Park, and for other purposes, approved August 24, 1935 (49 Stat. 795) says "the
Secretary of the Interior shall be, and he is hereby, authorized and directed to transfer to the control and jurisdiction
of the Secretary of the Navy for naval radio purposes the site of the relocated radio station, with the buildings and
improvements thereon, and such surrounding areas as may be agreed upon by the Secretary of the Interior and the
Secretary of the Navy: Provided That the Secretary of the Interior shall retain the right to approve the design of the
buildings and structures to be placed thereon including any additions or alterations to the present radio station."
28
Report on the Department of Defense Legacy Cold War Project, Coming in from the Cold: Military Heritage in
the Cold War,http://www.denix.osd.mil/denix/public/ES-programs/conservation/Cold War/coldwar.html. p. 42
defines the period as from the March 1946 "Iron Curtain" speech of Winston Churchill to the fall of the Berlin Wall
in 1989. But without the atomic explosions in Japan that opened the "Atomic Age" included, the dates do not seem
inclusive enough.
NSGA Winter Harbor Records - 28
Historical Note
standdown was called for at NSGA Winter Harbor. 29 The Navy purchased land at the nearby
fishing port, Corea, and built a Circular Disposed Antenna Array (CDAA), which became fully
operational in October 1963. An attempt was made to move administrative and support activities
to the Corea site in the 1960s, but the lack of sufficient drinking water at the site prevented the
move. So NSGA Winter Harbor continued its work, split between administration, public works,
maintenance, recreation and housing at Schoodic Point and operations at Corea. In the 1970s,
the Navy installed new satellite surveillance technologies at Corea and perhaps in other locations
in the vicinity. In the 1980s and 1990s, the Navy continued operations and used the base to
support its training mission.
Unfortunately, the record of accomplishments for the entire period remains almost entirely
classified, which makes evaluation for significance and interpretation difficult. Yet indirect
evidence can lead us to some conclusions. Documents such as the now-declassified information
about the work performed in Winter Harbor; the high level of funding poured into this remote
base for buildings, structures and maintenance; the high level of commanding officers who led
the staff, and the important jobs that they came from and went to at Winter Harbor; and the large
numbers of sailors and civilians who worked at the base until the closing process began all
indicate that the untold stories are likely to be extremely powerful. The base and its activities
30
during the Cold War are of the highest significance to that period of American and international
history, and should be handled as such. The periods that are significant in the story of the Navy
base and the national park are:
World War I and the establishment of naval communications at Otter Cliffs and
Seawall (1917-1919)
Relocation of the base from Otter Cliffs to Schoodic Point (1929-35)
World War II and the growth of the naval facility on Schoodic Point (1941-45)
The Cold War and expansion of the site at Corea and Winter Harbor (1945-1989)
Aftermath of Cold War and Base Closure (1989-2002)
EARLY HISTORY OF SCHOODIC PENINSULA
The internal areas of Schoodic Peninsula were little disturbed by roads or other development
until the middle of the nineteenth century. Thomas Frazier had developed a salt works near
Frazier's Creek in the 1790s. By the mid-nineteenth century, about fifty people lived in the area
and
supported
themselves by fishing. 31 Jabiz Myrick's property was noted on Walling's 1860
map of Hancock County. The Arey family lived on the Schoodic Peninsula until 1863, and
Adam Pendelton moved onto their abandoned property.
In contrast to what appears to have been a hardscrabble life at best on the peninsula, the town of
Bar Harbor profited from the summertime influxes of upper-class residents from Boston and
New York in the late 1880s. In 1887, in an attempt to emulate its successful neighbor, Winter
29
R. Christopher Goodwin & Associates, Inc., Navy Cold War Communication Context: Resources Associated with
the Navy's Communication Program, 1946-1989, Atlantic Division, Naval Facilities Engineering Command,
December 1997, p. A-11. This report will subsequently be cited as Cold War Context.
30
Coming in from the Cold, p. 14, suggests that among the questions to be asked of Cold War property types should
be "How much did the Department of Defense invest in them?" as one of the ways to establish significance.
31
CRS, ibid.
7.
Historical Note
NSGA Winter Harbor Records- 29
Harbor saw the establishment of the Beacon Hotel, but it closed three years later. At about the
same time, the Gouldsborough Land and Improvement Company organized to "purchase,
improve and sell land. ,,32 The company held land on both Grindstone Neck, just northwest of
Winter Harbor, and the Schoodic Peninsula and opened offices in New York City, Bar Harbor
and Winter Harbor. John G. Moore, Maine native, Wall Street financier, and the primary
Gouldsborough Land Company investor, began to purchase large tracts of land on the peninsula
and, in 1897, arranged for construction of a road to Schoodic Head SO that visitors might enjoy
the views of Mount Desert Island and other islands and bays along the coast. Moore died in
1898 before he could build his planned resort hotel on the top of Schoodic Head.
THE LANDSCAPE IN NINETEENTH CENTURY AMERICA
While Schoodic Peninsula developed slowly and in relative isolation, the same was not true for
Mount Desert Island just across Frenchman's Bay. The trend to summer in Bar Harbor arose
from a number of developments in nineteenth century life: transportation changes that made
travel to the remote area easier, growth of personal wealth in the Industrial Age, and the already
existing stunningly beautiful landscape of the region. In the nineteenth and twentieth centuries,
the American perception of the role of nature was affected by a number of intellectual and
cultural currents. Wealthy East Coast residents first became familiar with Mount Desert Island
partly as a result of the visits in the 1840s of American Hudson River School artists Thomas
Cole and Frederick Church, who painted the island landscapes and seascapes. As Jeff Pappas
33
points out, "At first, the national parks were seen as a way to broaden our appeal internationally:
to literally show the world that America was not just some cultural backwater content to
perpetuate European traditions. We were unique, and to illustrate our uniqueness we took an
obvious source: 'monumental landscapes' and made them symbols of our expanding empire."
American artists who adapted elements of English landscape painting to American sites in the
nineteenth century had a role in shaping expectations of how scenic reservations should look,
and it was as true for Mount Desert Island as it was for major western parks like Yosemite or the
35
Grand Canyon.
THE FORMATION OF ACADIA NATIONAL PARK
The scenic landscape movement, a Romantic nineteenth century preservation activity,
culminated in Maine with the formation of the Hancock Country Trustees of Public Reservations
in 1901. Wealthy summer residents of Mount Desert Island, led by textile heir George Dorr and
Harvard University president Charles W. Eliot, organized to protect a system of scenic paths and
trails constructed by village improvement groups from logging or development. By 1913, the
group had amassed enough land through donations and purchases to work to establish a national
monument. In 1916, the same year that the National Park Service was established, the Hancock
County Trustees' land holdings became Sieur de Monts National Monument.
32
CRS, ibid.
33
Leonard E. Brown, Acadia History, Acadia National Park, Maine History Basic Data, Office of History and
Historical Architecture, Eastern Service Center, National Park Service, Washington, DC, February 1971, pp. 37-49
and passim
34
Jeff Pappas, "Preface: Nature Study and the National Park Service," draft dissertation chapter, Department of
History, Arizona State University, August 2001, p.l.
35
Brown, ibid.
NSGA Winter Harbor Records - 30
Historical Note
In 1919, Lafayette National Park replaced the original national monument designation. This
national park was the first on the eastern seaboard and was accepted into the system partly as an
attempt on the part of the National Park Service administration in Washington to balance the
political and geographic presence of the Service throughout the United States.
36
The desire of
some wealthy Mount Desert Island residents to preserve what was an idealized, pre-settlement
landscape and to view it through carefully crafted means including viewpoints, paths and later
roads for automobiles, met the needs of a new government agency searching for widespread
political support to strengthen its presence in government. The combination of the two produced
a national park on Mount Desert Island. This cultural landscape has shaped one aspect of the
park and its story since its establishment.
An extension of that landscape continued at Schoodic. In September 1922, George Dorr, who
was by then the superintendent of Lafayette National Park, dined with a group of friends at the
Jordan Pond house. Among the guests were Mr. and Mrs. Warner M. Leeds, who apparently
lived near Dorr in Bar Harbor. During the course of the dinner, Mrs. Leeds, who was the widow
of Winter Harbor developer John C. Moore, offered Dorr her one-third interest in the peninsula,
which she held in equal shares with her two daughters who now lived in England. But Mrs.
Leeds died unexpectedly while visiting England, and Leeds, her widower and estate executor,
wanted to sell her share to the park. Leeds's demands appeared to doom the agreement.
However, Dorr managed to obtain the contingent assent of the two Moore daughters to the land
gift (it was contingent on their mother's share being part of the memorial to their father). Dorr
prevailed and, in addition, agreed to the wishes of the two daughters (who both now lived
permanently in England) that the name of the park be changed to something less French. Seven
years after the initial conversation at Jordan Pond, federal legislation changed the name of the
park to Acadia National Park and enabled the government to accept more land in outlying areas
of Hancock County. 37
THE MACHINE IN THE GARDEN
The acquisition of Schoodic Point and the surrounding lands added new assets to the assembling
of Acadia National Park and its culturally significant landscapes. But at virtually the same time,
a completely different twentieth century story, one rich with developing technology and wartime
strategic success, was developing at Otter Cliffs, one of the scenic points on the southeastern side
of Mount Desert Island. The era of wireless communications began in 1843, when Samuel F.B.
Morse first wired a message from Washington to Baltimore, but by the latter 1890s, in the same
period that Bar Harbor was at the height of its wealth and influence as a summer playground, the
Italian inventor Guglielmo Marconi recognized that there was commercial potential in
transmitting radio waves. The U.S. Navy began testing wireless apparatus in 1899, and the first
official radio message was sent from ship to shore that year. The Navy also funded
communications research, both internally and by contractors. From 1902 onward, the Navy was
36
Hal Rothman, America's National Monuments: The Politics of Preservation (Lawrence: University of Kansas
Press, 1994).
12
Sargent F. Collier, Mount Desert Island & Acadia National Park: An Informal History (Camden, Maine: Down
East Books, 1978, pp. 123-125.
38
The title comes from Leo Marx, The Machine in the Garden: Technology and the Pastoral Ideal in America
(New York: Oxford University Press, 1964).
Historical Note
NSGA Winter Harbor Records- 31
"a significant market" for radio communications products. 39
THE U.S. NAVY AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF RADIO COMMUNICATIONS
President Theodore Roosevelt, in recognition of the Navy's early acceptance of the new
technology, placed the service in charge of government radio operations. By 1904, the Navy had
established nineteen short wave radio stations. In addition, the US Navy Radio Laboratory was
opened in 1908 to conduct research on vacuum tubes and other components that made voice
transmission possible. By that time, the Navy had also developed a chain of stations capable of
relaying messages between the Atlantic and Pacific coasts. Coverage of the north Atlantic and
continental U.S. was achieved by a high-power transmitter NAA Arlington based at Ft. Myer,
Virginia in 1913. Congress authorized the Navy to construct a chain of stations in the Canal
Zone, California, Hawaii, American Samoa, Guam, and the Philippines. When the first station at
Chollas Heights in San Diego went on line in 1917, it was the most powerful radio transmitter in
North America. 40
When World War I began, the Navy was government communications and needed to develop
equipment for secure communications, interception techniques, and cryptoanalysis. In addition,
President Wilson directed the Navy to establish and operate a transatlantic communications
system with headquarters at Belmar, New Jersey. As a historian of the period recounts, "This
system comprised facilities taken over by the Navy from commercial interests
the facilities
included transmitting stations located at New Brunswick and Tuckerton, New Jersey and
Sayville, New York; and receiving stations at Belmar, New Jersey; Chatham, Massachusetts; and
Bar Harbor, Maine. ,,41
NBD RADIO BAR HARBOR
Before World War I, a wealthy New Yorker, who was perhaps a member of the Italian nobility,
established amateur radio stations, or what would now be called "ham radio operations" on his
yacht and in his family's summer house on Mount Desert Island. Alessandro Fabbri, whose
brother Ernesto was a banker with J. P. Morgan in New York and who had married a Vanderbilt
daughter, was an enthusiastic amateur radio operator. One evening, probably in the spring of
1917, Fabbri invited Franklin Delano Roosevelt, then the assistant Secretary of the Navy, to
dinner in Bar Harbor. After dinner, Fabbri turned on one of his long-wave radio receivers (he had
built it himself) and they listened to the signals coming from station POZ, in Nauen, Germany
where a regular daily broadcast from German naval leaders went out to German vessels all over
the world. Roosevelt knew that on orders from President Wilson, the Navy had been trying to
intercept messages from Nauen radio. The Navy had established the Belmar, New Jersey station
and an additional one in Newfoundland but had not been successful. Fabbri, on the other hand,
appeared to be intercepting everything and the transmissions were clear.
42
Roosevelt asked for copies of the Nauen contacts and took them back to Washington with him.
The Navy immediately sent Chief Radioman Ray Cole to Fabbri's estate in Bar Harbor. Fabbri
39
Cold War Context, p. 10.
40
Ibid., pp. 10-11.
41
Ibid., p. 12.
42
Emily Ellsworth, "Echoes from Otter Cliffs," Down East, November 1964, p. 30; Brandon Wentworth, The
Fabulous Radio NBD (Southwest Harbor, Me: Beech Hill Publishing Company, 1984), p.6.
NSGA Winter Harbor Records - 32
Historical Note
was commissioned in June 1917, although not without a great deal of discussion and lobbying.
He was placed in charge of his own equipment at Otter Cliffs, the land that Fabbri leased for the
Navy from the owner, who had leased it to the Bar Harbor Country Club. 43 The Naval reserve
radio operators at Belmar, New Jersey were transferred north and the latest Naval radio
1917
equipment was shipped to Bar Harbor. On August 28, 1917, Naval Radio- Bar Harbor started up
with the call letters "NBD". Seawall was constructed in the next year SO that outgoing messages
could be "keyed" at Otter Cliffs and transmitted at Seawall. Otter Cliffs originally had only a 1
kilowatt spark transmitter, and the Seawall transmitter was particularly needed to communicate
with ships. The Otter Cliffs receiving equipment consisted of two 125-foot towers and loop
antennae and counterpoise that Fabbri "had devised and built at his own expense." Barracks
were built and a barbed wire fence erected around the area. Fifty Navy enlisted men, most right
out of training courses at Harvard College, arrived to join the original thirty other enlisted
44
personnel and a detachment of Marines who had been sent for security. There were both ship-
to-shore circuits and transatlantic circuits. The receivers were housed in small shacks, each with
its own antenna and each assigned the call letters of a European station: POZ for Nauen,
Germany; YN for Lyons, France, and others.
Fabbri's station was used to pass most of the official communications between the battlefronts in
45
Europe and Washington. They often received 20,000 words a day, most of them in cipher.
The
receiver tuned in to POZ in October 1918 intercepted the first message from Kaiser Wilheim to
President Woodrow Wilson asking to negotiate an armistice. Bar Harbor was the only station in
the US to pick up this message clearly and completely. As a result, it was also the only station in
the U.S. used for President Wilson's communications with Washington from the peace talks in
Paris. Thus, World War I is the first period of significance in the mutual history of the Navy
46
and the National Park.
Immediately after World War I, the Otter Cliffs station continued its ship-to-shore traffic, which
increased dramatically. The radiomen distributed messages from returning soldiers still at sea to
their families. The four radiomen assigned to the ship-to-shore frequencies worked eight-hour
shifts in rotation SO that the radio was available 24 hours a day. In addition to the ship
communications, Otter Cliffs communicated with airborne radios. In the case of a trans-Atlantic
flight by Navy seaplanes in May 1919, Otter Cliffs established a new, plane-to-ground
communications record of 1250 miles and by the time one of the planes landed in the Azores,
Bar Harbor was listening across a distance of 1900 miles. Naval radio at Bar Harbor also aided
the British airship R-34 from Scotland to New York in July 1919 SO successfully that the
dirigible asked that Bar Harbor monitor its flight home. The radio station collected weather
reports from ships at sea across the Atlantic and communicated the information to the airship.
This was perhaps the first time that weather reports, seven hundred in all during the course of the
47
seventy-two hour journey, were communicated in this way to a vehicle during flight.
With the end of the war, however, the armed forces began to disband and the reservists at the
location received their discharges. Some returned as regular Navy personnel, but the central role
43
Wentworth, p. 7 and accompanying photo.
44
Ellsworth, p. 31.
45
Bill Continelli, W2XOY, The Wayback Machine, #4, http://www.hudson-loop.org/waybak4.html.
46
Collier, p. 128.
47
Ellsworth, p. 40.