From collection Creating Acadia National Park: The George B. Dorr Research Archive of Ronald H. Epp

Page 1

Page 2

Page 3

Page 4

Page 5

Page 6

Page 7

Page 8

Page 9

Page 10

Page 11

Page 12

Page 13

Page 14

Page 15

Page 16

Page 17

Page 18

Page 19

Page 20
Search
results in pages
Metadata
Ellsworths John A Peters Esq and the Father of Acadia Ellsworth PL July 28, 2016
"Ellsworth's John A. Peters, Esq. & the Father of Acadia"
Ellsworth P.L., July 28, 2016
7/3/16
1
"Ellsworth's John A. Peters, Esq. & the 'Father of Acadia'
Ronald H. Epp Ph.D.
Ellsworth Public Library
July 28, 2016
Thank you for this opportunity to speak about one of Ellsworth's
most distinguished citizens, focusing not on his legal career but
instead on his relationship with George B. Dorr, Acadia's 'Father.'
Even though this library was erected on what is historically known
as the Peters Block, I'll remind one and all that John Andrew
Peters (1864-1953) attended Ellsworth public schools before
moving on to graduate from Bowdoin (1885). Two years later he
gained membership in Phi Beta Kappa. He would come to hold
many of the titles of his same-named uncle. Admitted to the bar,
in 1887 Peters Jr. started a practice in Ellsworth where he was
judge of the municipal court from 1896-1908 until he was elected
to three-terms in the Maine House, and a four-term member of
the U.S. Congress where he represented the Third District for
nine years. He maintained a reduced private practice.
In 1918 he successfully advanced in the House a bill passed in
the Senate (S. 4957) to establish Lafayette National Park. In
1922 he returned to the law as Associate Justice of the Maine
Supreme Judicial Court, two years before he became a member
of the HCTPR. Warren Harding appointed him Judge of the United
States District Court, an office he held until 1947 when he retired.
That year he completed the disposition of the Dorr estate, six
years before his death in 1953. His office archive is located three
hundred feet distant in the attic of the offices of Hale and Hamlin
(much more about this firm later)
2
Knitting together the benchmarks in the Dorr-Peters relationship
is not a topic I discussed in my biography of Mr. Dorr. In fact,
establishing precisely when the Dorr-Peters relationship began
has not been possible. In Dorr's published memoir, The Story of
Acadia National Park, he says that before 1913 Peters "had aided
me professionally in various matters at Bar Harbor and I knew
him, well." According to a biographical profile written by
Ellsworth's Herbert T. Silsby II, following Peters admission to the
bar he practiced law briefly in Bar Harbor before relocating to
Ellsworth; at this time he and Dorr may have established a
relationship.
In 1913, twelve years after the HCTPR was established as the
second American land trust, Peters writes (three decades later)
that a bill was introduced in the Maine legislature to revoke" its
charter...[for] it did not matter that the commercial value of its
lands were small and the scenic value immense [since] some
people could not see beyond their own noses." And here the vivid
language of Peters has its fullest expression: Dorr "descended
upon the Maine Legislature like an aroused lion in defense of its
cubs." Peters says that the battle was "one-sided..[for] there was
no resisting Mr. Dorr when fighting for the public welfare." Peters
does not mention here that he was Speaker of the House and
that for ten days he and Dorr raised the profile of the Trustees
among the members of the Maine legislature.. (Dedication of the
George Bucknam Dorr Memorial, 1947)
Complicating our understanding of the evolving relationship
between the two men is the small number of surviving letters
from Dorr to Judge Peters. None have been found in Park
archives, not surprising since so many documents were
irresponsibly discarded by the NPS in the town landfill after Dorr's
death. Dorr wrote to Peters in February of 1915 detailing
3
expenses and revenue needed to advance national park status for
the national monument but there is nothing here that discloses
Dorr's view of Peters' character. Even though firm bonds between
the two were developing out of their common concern for the
preservation of landscape within Hancock County, throughout
Dorr's life he relied principally on verbal persuasion.
sternand,
"Frightened" about the whimsical nature of state and local
through
legislatures, Dorr convinced President Eliot in 1913 (to offer "his
child to the federal government for adoption." Having become a
Charles.
U.S. congressman, Peters states that the two fought "jealousy as
ACTER
well as ignorance and the usual governmental inertia." Finally,
after Peters secured an appointment, they went to the White
keek
House to meet with President Woodrow Wilson. He told Wilson
that Dorr was the most public-spirited man he had ever known,
quite a claim for a Mainer in the nation's capital. Shortly
July
8
thereafter, a June 25, 1916 proclamation federalized roughly
5,000 acres of island landscape as Sieur de Monts National
Monument.
Peters
concludes
his
remarks
by
acknowledgi Eig
the assistance of
other public-spirited citizens, insisting that the Park owes much to
them; but more to Mr. Dorr than to all others, because he gave
all he had." Similar remarks were voiced two months later (on
Refunds
August 22nd ) during a celebration at the Building of the Arts in
Bar Harbor. For those inclined to see the work of divine
bureur
Providence in what others see as coincidence, exactly 10 years to
mouth
the day after this celebration, Dr. Charles W. Eliot died at his
home in Northeast Harbor. For dismiss this
as
coincidence, Cone should take into account the fact that John A.
Peters died on August 22, 1953, thirty-seven years to the day
after the celebration, twenty-seven years to the day after Eliot's
death. Parenthetically, John Quincy Adams called the coincidence
4
of his father's death on the 50th anniversary of the signing of the
Declaration of Independence -- and within hours of Thomas
Jefferson's death-- a "visible and palpable remark of Divine
Favor".
Three days after the Building of the Arts celebration, the National
Park Service was established and the effort to elevate the
national monument to national park status began. Congressman
Peters and Maine U.S. Senator Frederick Hale both draft bills in
1918 to that effect. When news was received in September 1918
that the national monument passed through the committee
structures, an editorial in the Kennebec Journal praised John A.
Peters for a record of service to the state and the nation "that is
unsurpassed by that of any statesman
Fand
President [Wilson]
recognizes a reliable, patriotic statesman of breadth and power,
loyal to every national interest, and too big to play politics."
(9.11.1918)
As I explained in chapter 16 of my biography, despite park
growth and popular local and national success in the first years of
park development, by 1922 the seeds of resident discord were
sprouting. Not only were park officials planning a Cadillac
Mountain summit road but also a bisecting motor road enabling
rangers to pass easily between the northern and southern sides
of the mountain; at the same time news was received that Mr.
Rockefeller was not only prepared to cover the cost of a motor
an 8-mile
road network but also planned the extension of his carriage road
system
some
eight miles to encircle Jordan, Sargent, and
Parkman mountains. How would all this development be viewed
by the seasoned village improvement associations, especially
groups of hikers concerned about the erosion of island wild lands?
5
In July of 1922 such concerns went unmentioned when Judge
Peters was guest of honor at an Echo Lake luncheon hosted by
the AMC. Though the documentation is scant and ill-defined, it
was
appears that this event the handiwork of Mr. Dorr who had
owned the 13 acres of land by Beech Cliff until he deeded it to the
outdoor organization as a base of island-wide exploration. The
AMC would later accept the gift as a memorial to the park founder
but on this occasion Peters described Dorr in a particularly
memorable way: the park superintendent is "our own prince of
altruists."
Despite such accolades, a summer resident of Northeast Harbor
and U.S. Senator from Pennsylvania by the name of George
Wharton Pepper had
aroused popular support for
protection of interior wildlands. Private warnings to Dorr and
fellow Trustees escalated into threats from this primitivist that
Park road construction would be brought to the floor of the U.S.
last
Senate. As I mention in my article
this
month in the FOA Journal,
Pepper strained public credulity when he said that visitor
experience atop Cadillac would be marred by the sight of any
vehicle not there when Champlain discovered the island! Dorr and
Rockefeller could not be intimidated So Pepper requested
a
meeting with the new Interior secretary, physician Hubert Work.
Peters played a key role in arrangements for the Road Hearings.
He first acted as a mediator, writing collegial letters to Pepper
explaining the rationale for development in the hope that a
meeting with the Secretary could be avoided. Pepper so as
proclude the need for the March 1924 hearing (3.8.1924) That
proved ineffective, and fellow Trustee, Seal Harbor relator George
L. Stebbins, wrote to Peters about preparatory planning being
executed independent of Dorr, for some fear " that if Mr. Dorr is
in charge he will try to prove too much and talk too long." There
6
was
the well-intentioned effort to "relieve Mr. Dorr of that sort of
responsibility.' " The views of other summer residents are
described, including some who are so set against Senator Pepper
that efforts will be made to keep their views confined to paper
rather than verbal comments that would "rile things up." There was
confidence that the proposed road development plans will be would be
approved Dorr's allies can prevent the superintendent from trying
to prove too much. Bear in mind that Pepper distaste for what he
perceived as Dorr's free-hand led the Senator to propose creation
of a governmental oversight committee to counteract Dorr's alleged
overuse of his authority.
Pepper had a way of getting under the skin of Peters as well. The
Congressman wrote to fellow Maine congressman Ira G. Hersey,
that "One man from Pennsylvania, even if he is a senator, should
not control the destinies of all the people of Maine. think it is
an outrage on us, but I cannot say that except to you." Dorr
Arno
admitted to the NPS director (Cammerer) more than a decade
later that if this case had been decided in Pepper's favor "it would
have spelt disaster to the park," for the role of Mr. Rockefeller
would have been narrowed or worse; the very existence of the
Abbe Museum & the JAX might have been negated if Dorr's hands
had been slapped as Pepper intended. But the case was settled in
favor of the "defendants."
This is not to say that Dorr and Peters did not differ on a few Park
development issues. Most notable was the mountain naming
controversy which came to public attention at the onset of the
Great Depression. Since 1918 Dorr had applied for permission
(from the U.S. Board on Geographic Names) to rename island
mountains whose ancestry was unknown or undistinguished-that
is, those that lacked historical associations (Dry, Round, etc.).
Relatively quickly more than a dozen mountains were renamed,
7
irritating conservatives who favored the old names. The Trustees
were divided in their loyalties and some sought to undo what Dorr
had achieved. Peters writes in 1930 that he favors local history
for "I think it a shame to abuse them [as when] Mr. Dorr called
one "Cadillac," and I told him at the time, if he was going to do
that he ought to call another one "Buick" and certainly a peak
near Seal Harbor ought to be called 'Ford.' Is this tongue-in-
cheek or a serious disagreement? The jury is still out
This chiding by Peters is related to another area of common
concern, the impact of increased tourism on park management
and the NPS role as the county's foremost agent of preservation.
these
The phenomenal success of the automobile not only increased
vehicles
park visitation system-wide, tourists arrived with expectations
about an array of services: hotels, lodges, gift shops,
campgrounds, restaurants, service stations, and an increasing
array
of
concessions (e.g., MDI water and ocean
transports) geared to the local environment As the Great
depression years arrived, golf links, tennis courts, swimming
pools, and other outdoor pastime facilities were planned for some
parks (M. Mantell, "Preservation and Use: Concessions in the
National Parks"), but at Acadia Dorr through his weight
behind CCC development of park infrastructure.
The NPS evolved strict policies governing concessions within its
holdings, a lesser issue at Acadia since supportive services ringed
the park. Conversations about these issues between Dorr,
Rockefeller, Peters, and others led to the formation of the Acadia
Corporation in 1933 (Because of his official position, Dorr had ex-
officio status). One of its presidents, Charles Savage, wrote that
it is "owned and directed by people whose primary interest is
Mount Desert and the preservation of its traditions," that is year-
round and seasonal residents of Hancock County.
8
Despite the lofty rhetoric, Rockefeller candidly wrote that he
Acadia Corporation was formed "because it was thought that
some such organization was necessary in order to protect the
park against concessionaires from outside who [would likely
ignore] MDI traditions." (RAC. B.62.f.620. 10.27.41) Local control
involved shares of stock to raise capital, with little promise that
the revenue would be sufficient over time to pay dividends.
Peters was a Director whose career credentials positioned him to
shoulder for nearly two decades continuing relationships with the
most senior yet distant NPS officials
and
who
an
officio
AC.
Yet it was not only private enterprise that required strict
OF
oversight the Department of Defense under war power acts laid
1941
claim to the summit of Cadillac as a military observatory, They
prohibit access for more than five years not only by the public
but also by the NPS. When the Army released the summit,
buildings owned by the Acadia Corporation were left in ruin, with
no recompense forthcoming. Knowing of Dorr's convictions about
the summit, Peters was as persistent as the superintendent would
have been. He fought against the Army position "that the Acadia
Corporation exclusion from our place of doing business, was not a
particular damage to us." (RAC. B. 62.f. 622. D. Rodick to JDR Jr.
6/22/45)
One year before Dorr's death, the Father of Acadia finalized
another will and named John A. Peters his Executor, stating that
he had "complete trust and confidence" in him and four estate
trustees: family friend Mary Hale, her son Richard W. Hale Jr., the
president of Bowdoin College, and Dorr's secretary, Phyllis S.
Sylvia. The superintendent had been afflicted with impaired sight
since his teenage years. In his final months, residing in Storm
Beach Cottage, Dorr admitted that he could no longer see; when
9
visited in the final months by Peters and other Trustees, Dorr's
identity
in tact.
remainded
Dorr's death on 5 August 1944 prompted the administration of
the Dorr estate. Yet prior to that complicated process, Peters
proposed one week later at the annual HCTPR meeting that the
Trustees take steps to rename Dry Mountain as Dorr Mountain, a
renaming approved by the USBGN on February 20, 1945.
Peters was immediately faced with actions undertaken by the
park service that were either unspecified in the Dorr estate plans
or at odds with it. For example, "As negotiated several years
earlier, the inventoried possessions became federal property
a
few would be added to the collections of the park archives." The
bulk were sold, including the contents of a twenty-by-forty foot
Park Library. While some park documents accumulated over a
thirty year career were salvaged, the majority
were
sent
glammed
the landfill A small safe contained family letters and
most
correspondence with prominent literary and political figures-th
these documents
Mary Hale directed to appropriate New England historical societies
and Harvard University. (CANP, 306) Bear in mind that Beters still
had judicial responsibilities and was not on site to see how fellow
Trustees and park staff evaluated and disposed of the estate
content. But written reports were sent to Peters and this is how
we know of specific actions. Because Only the records of Judge
their
Peters were preserved over the last sixty years.
fallness
This is the fascinating story that ought to find its place into local
history. It is a classic tale of hiding in plain sight. Located in the
Peters Block--in the attic of Hale and Hamlin since 1953-- was a
treasure vital to understanding the history of Acadia National
Park, not to mention the evolution of Ellsworth. Here was the law
10
office of Judge Peters. Whether the attorneys working there were
aware of this is unclear to this day. Nowhere in the public record
that I have uncovered is there an indication that this legal office
existed. Why the silence you might ask?
Bear in mind that confidentiality is foundational to the client-
attorney relationship. Keeping private matters private is
essential, Historically, legal archives are not part of the scholar's
enterprise
their
to
domain, regardless of their usefulness to historical completeness
and truth. At the death of a client, records are directed to family
members or a designated recipient; if these are not available, the
records are destroyed. Yet in an attic nearby the John A. Peters
archive endured.
And how was it uncovered? A contractor roofing the Woodlawn
Museum mentioned to the Executive Director (Josh Torrance) that
his crew had just opened the roof downtown at Hale and Hamlin.
When they looked down between the rafters an intact office
remained amid the attic debris. This casual comment prompted
Josh to contact Hale & Hamlin, explaining his interest from a
Trustee perspective. Permission was secured in early October
2008 when Josh, local archivist Martha Harmon, Woodlawn
collections manager Roz Rae and I gingerly stepped across rafters
into the enclosed office.
I had traveled then from New Hampshire because of the
relationship between Dorr and Peters; my research had led me to
conclude falsely that the Peters archive had been lost. Yet here
were bound legal tomes, a professional library, and a phenomenal
225 lineal feet of numbered files containing matters of public
record but also a vast collection of private correspondence
relating to Woodlawn, Bowdoin College, HCTPR, Ellsworth, and
11
the establishment and development of ANP. We were permitted
to move resources to a work area on the floor below, remove
layers of dust, and photocopy unique documents that bore the
signatures of Dorr, Rockefeller, and Roosevelt amid a bounty of
persons, names, and issues of interest to scholarly communities
at the local, state, and national level.
Of special interest were hundreds of pages of unique
correspondence relative to Peters role as executor of the estate of
Mr. Dorr. And to think that this had come to my attention as I
was completing the first draft of my biography of the park
founder! Photocopying was just the start of a research process
involving the investigation of hundreds of new data elements,
previlously unresearched persons and events, an$d the
integration of my findings into new drafts of the concluding
chapters of the Dorr biography. In the end, the historical record
of Dorr's achievement had been significantly amplified; and the
actions
rate of Judge Peters elevated the contributions of local figures to
the establishment and development of Acadia National Park. As
far as I know, that archive-- several hundred feet away-has not
been inventoried and remains in the state it was when we
examined it.
In the concluding chapter of the Dorr biography, I trace in great
detail the activity of Judge Peters in administering the Dorr
estate. Suffice it to say, his continuing personal attention to the
complexities of the estate plan over more than three years
provides all the evidence needed about the character of speters
esteem for Dorr and the depth$ of their friendship. This obligation
was undertaken as the promise of retirement vied with continuing
Dorr
judicial responsibilities. When the estate was finally settled in
November 1947, roughly $25,000 was available for distribution
(one-quarter went to the HCTPR); the commission earned by
12
Judge Peters for his labor over four years was $338.57 (After
inflation, in 2016 currency this is $3,640).
tookover
Peters assumed Dorr's role of bringing to Rockefeller's attention
Echo Lake properties that the philanthropist might want to
purchase as an addition to the Park (RAC.B.98.f.968.7.21.1945;
7.12.45;7.31.45). This led to difficulties since some were Dorr
properties that Rockefeller believed ought to be gifted to the
federal government directly through the estate; Dorr's executors saw
them as a revenue generator to offset Dorr's debts and to
raise funds for other projects that part of his estate plan.
were
Hundreds of pages in the Peters archive detail projects outside
the scope of Dorr's will that were conceived and painstakingly
executed by the judge. The well recognized Sieur de Monts Spring
memorial stone honoring "the Father of Acadia" involved
assistance from Ben Hadley, the new superintendent. A plaque
once designed would be affixed to a large slab of granite taken
from the summit of Cadillac. A Harvard chum of Dorr named R.
Clipston Sturgis-the former president of the American Institute
of Architects-agreed to design the tablet. The iconic language on
that tablet was adapted by Peters from the 1936 memorial to
Boston banker James Jackson Storrow. Again, Peters tried his
best to honor Dorr's principled partiality to contextualize actions
within "historical associations." All of this could have been lost to
the historical record were it not for a chatty roofing contractor, a
zealous Woodlawn director, and an agreeable group of Ellsworth
lawyers.
When completed, Judge Peters gave the keynote address at the
August 29, 1947 dedication of the Dorr Memorial in the grassy
area at the Sieur de Monts Spring. The narrative is not a eulogy.
13
What follows is Peter's adept characterization of his friend: "he
was resourceful, indefatigable, and irresistible. A modest
scholarly gentleman, a philosopher, a scientist, a man dealing
with ideas [In those years beginning with the 1913 challenge to
the Maine legislature] Dorr seemingly turned into a shrewd, hard-
boiled, effective master-lobbyist" despite the belief that he was
"somewhat impractical in business affairs." For "he appeared to
know the strings that control men's actions and how to pull
them."
A man who had served both state and federal governments
reminded us that "government inertia clog (s) initiative and had
to be overcome by [the] personal energy and intelligent
persistence" of George B. Dorr." Unfortunately, Peters continues,
the Government cannot be counted on to express the
appreciation and gratitude of its citizens for such altruistic effort
[as demonstrated by Mr. Dorr]." Consequently, it remains for the
Trustees "to advise posterity of the name of their benefactor and
the boundaries of his life." of
this
remained
kidden
from
posterity
were
it
not
for
roofing
contractor
zealous
Woodlawn
director,
and
an
agreeable
group
lawyers.
Two months after the dedication, the MDI fire of October 1947
ruined the Dorr memorial. The memorial we stand before these
days replaced the original. When Peters writes to Rockefeller
about this loss, the philanthropist's response is one of sorrow. Yet
he reminds Peters that "like the boulder on which the tablet was
erected, which neither fire nor frost will effect throughout the
ages, stands the record on the Island itself of Mr. Dorr's great life
work."
lays bare
14
that
In conclusion, I hope this talk outlines the contribution of a
Ellsworth native to the conservation of landscape now
incorporated in Acadia National Park. His legal colleagues and
close associates in Bar Harbor, Luere B. Deasy and A.H. Lynam,
did far more than render legal services. They went beyond the
parameters of their profession both in terms of their relationships
with their clients and in service to the core principles of
conservation that their judgments helped advance. All three, in
my judgment, are founders of Acadia National Park.
When John Peters was considering retirement from the Bench, he
undertook--at 80 years of age--this three year project that
advanced the Dorr legacy. Ben Hadley had argued that by this
in 20K
day Dorr's legacy would be forgotten. Because of Peters' actions
and the uncovering of this hidden archive, Hadley was proven
wrong. There was more than one "Prince of Altruists." The words
that Peters applied to Dorr in 1925 describe the speaker as well,
since the sacrifices of both resulted in the creation, growth, and
development of Acadia National Park.
Dorr & Peters_EPL_716
To:
Joshua Torrance
From:
Ronald Epp
Date:
9 October 2008
Re:
Papers of Hon. John A. Peters
In a one hundred and fifty square foot enclosed attic space of the Ellsworth (ME) Hale and
Hamlin office building, a professional library, legal documents, and extensive correspondence of
John A. Peters (1864-1953) were uncovered in September 2008 during the installation of a new
roof. It cannot be determined if what is extant constitutes the whole of his professional papers.
Since his retirement from the bench in the mid-1940's, it appears that the collection was
untouched. Most resources were shelved, poorly identified (if at all), and not arranged. Many
were scattered on the floor, more deteriorated than the bulk of the collection.
Ellsworth native John Andrew Peters (1864-1953) was educated at Bowdoin College where he
received the A.B. (1885), and read law prior to received the A.M. (1888) degree. Two decades of
private practice in Ellsworth (1887-1908) were marked by service as a Judge in the Municipal
Court of Ellsworth (1896-1908), three terms as Maine state representative, and a U.S.
Representative from Maine (1913-22) prior to appointment to the U.S. District Court, District of
Maine where he served more than two decades.
Woodlawn Museum Executive Director Joshua Torrance immediately recognized the cultural
significance of this collection and enlisted the aid of Woodlawn curator Rosamond Rea, archivist
Martha Harmon and library consultant Ronald H. Epp. Ph.D. With the exception of bound legal
tomes (many originally belonged to his namesake uncle), the Peters collection was relocated to a
work area where layers of superficial dirt were removed, legal documents were segregated, and
the remaining correspondence received a cursory examination.
The documents span seven decades (1885-1950), with the bulk concentrated in the
1915-45 timeframe. Since this was an initial survey, no comprehensive inventory was undertaken
although more attention was given to documentation that related to the professional interests of
the inquirers: that is, documentation on the Black House, Bowdoin College, the Hancock County
Trustees of Public Reservations (HCTPR), the establishment of the Sieur de Monts National
Monument on Mount Desert Island, the development of Acadia National Park, and attorneys
Deasy, Lynam, and Rodick. The relationship of Judge Peters with the Black family (and
Woodlawn officials), George Bucknam Dorr, Beatrix Farrand, the Richard W. Hale family, John
D. Rockefeller Jr., and George L. Stebbins received scrutiny.
There are approximately 225 lineal feet of documents, all but 25 feet being thousands of legal
documents that have a numbering scheme; no client index has been uncovered. These packets
most likely duplicate documents that are in the public record though sampling discloses
correspondence contained therein in more than a few instances.
The Peters correspondence provides the richest cultural information. Black House documentation
is more than incidental, the life of Beatrix Farrand is expanded by new findings, and Peters role
as a Bowdoin College Trustee is treated superficially. On the other hand, the collection includes
hundreds of pages of unique documents relating to the Acadia National Park founder George
Bucknam Dorr (1853-1944), in large part because Peters was executor of Dorr's estate.
Cumulatively, these areas of special interest represent less than five percent of the
correspondence.
Hale and Hamlin should be informed in writing as soon as possible of the significance of this
intellectual legacy. Hopefully, they will release the stewardship of this collection to Joshua
Torrance. These resources contain a bounty of persons, themes, and issues of interest to the
scholarly community. Graduate students and seasoned scholars now have the opportunity to
examine Peters biographically, placing him within the legal, political, and social territory
spanning the decades between the Civil War and the end of the WWII.
Since the social impact of Peters was felt primarily in Maine, every effort should be made to find
an institutional setting within the State where the resources will be expeditiously processed and
made available to the public, attaching the requirement that within a specified timeframe that a
searchable fulsome online finding aid will be available to researchers. A law library may be
interested in the entire collection, including the legal tomes On the other hand, it is the
correspondence that will arouse the greatest interest. To that end, the character of the collection
seems most suitable for the complementary collections of the Maine Historical Society. Its
location in Portland also speaks for its accessibility to researchers who will find there related
collections, a situation that may not be equaled elsewhere in the State.
On the assumption that the collection remains intact, alternative repositories that should be
considered are Special Collections at the University of Maine (Orono) and Bowdoin College.
On the other hand some organizations may not have an interest in the whole of the collection-
they may accept it and then dispose of what is not germane to their interests. Acadia National
Park would likely have interest solely in that part of the collection related to Park historical
development. Similarly, the Maine State Archives collection policies may be too restrictive given
our initial experience with the array of correspondence; moreover, a recent online search of their
holdings discloses nothing especially of interest about Judge Peters.
Input from the Maine State Historian should be invited. Discrete inquiries should be made to
several repositories before an agreement is formalized. A status report should be provided to the
HCTPR at their next scheduled meeting-and the media should be informed when a decision is
reached on the relocation of the Peters Papers.
At this time it is not clear what criteria will guide the decision on where the public will best be
served by depositing the Peters Papers. Input from team members that initially analyzed the
collection is important. When an agreement is struck with the organization that will conserve
these Papers, written assurances that the Hon. John A. Peters Papers will be fully processed and
made available to the public within a specified timeframe must be secured. This is the least that
can be expected in order to honor the quality of John A. Peter's character and the extraordinary
level of service provided to clients.
4/12/2016
XFINITY Connect
XFINITY Connect
eppster2@comcast.net
+ Font Size
Re: Ellsworth Event
From : Sandy Abbott
Tue, Apr 12, 2016 12:46 PM
Subject : Re: Ellsworth Event
To : Ronald Epp
Hello Ron,
Thank you so much for your prompt reply! I have confirmed the date on
our calendar for July 28 at 6:00 pm.
If we can come up with a title and brief 2-3 sentences for a brief
description, be fore the day ends, I can submit it to Down East
Magazine and meet the deadline for the Special ANP Centennial Edition
coming out in June.
Will you be doing a PowerPoint presentation?
Do you ask an honorarium?
Will you have books available for sale and signing?
I am looking forward to your presentation.
Best,
Sandy
Quoting "Ronald Epp" :
> Dear Sandy,
>
> Thank you for the compliment about the Dorr biography.
>
> The EPL was on my list of libraries to approach about an event and
> so I was pleased to receive your invite.
> July 28 at 6 p.m. would work for me. Please confirm this.
>
> I'll be passing through Ellsworth April 22nd and will stop by to
> introduce myself and get a more recent
> sense of the lay of the land. I've been scheduled for a "Talk of the
> Towns" radio interview at nearby WERU
> that morning.
>
> I've attached a copy of my C.V.
>
> Looking forward to this experience.
>
> Cordially,
>
> Ron
>
> Original Message
>
> From: "Sandy Abbott"
> To: eppster2@comcast.net
> Sent: Monday, April 11, 2016 12:20:01 PM
> Subject: Ellsworth Event
>
> Dear Ronald,
>
> I was thrilled to receive two copies of your recent book for our
> library collection!
https://web.mail.comcast.net/zimbra/h/printmessage?id=363825&z=America/New_York&xim=1
1/2
4/12/2016
XFINITY Connect
> As a Centennial Partner, our library has a self imposed commitment to
> offer a program each month supporting the ANP Centennial. I am aware
> that you will be doing presentations in different areas. How would you
> feel about sharing your knowledge and book at the Ellsworth Public
> Library in July? I currently have Thursday July 14 at 6:00 pm or
> Thursday July 28 at 6:00 pm available. I could possibly do something
> in August, but I think that is too close to the Blue Hill Library
> offering.
>
> Thank you for your consideration, looking forward to your reply.
>
> Sandy
>
>
>
> Sandy Abbott
> Assistant Director
>
> Ellsworth Public Library
> 20 State ST
> Ellsworth ME 04605
> 207-667-6363
> www.ellsworth.lib.me.us
>
>
Sandy Abbott
Assistant Director
Ellsworth Public Library
20 State ST
Ellsworth ME 04605
207-667-6363
www.ellsworth.lib.me.us
https://web.mail.comcast.net/zimbra/h/printmessage?id=363825&tz=America/New_York&xim=
2016 ACP Revised Scheduled Events for Ron Epp
July 28
"Ellsworth's John A. Peters' Relationship to the
'Father' of Acadia National Park."
Ellsworth Public Library. 6:00 p.m.
August 3
"Writing about Conservation Giants: Two Decades of
Living with G.B. Dorr, C.W. Eliot, and JDR Jr."
Northeast Harbor Public Library. 5:30 p.m.
August 10 "Surprising Revelations: Intimacies in Letters between
Charles W. Eliot, G.B. Dorr, and J.D. Rockefeller Jr."
Jesup Memorial Library. 7:00 p.m.
August 16 "Creating Acadia National Park."
Camden Public Library. 7:00 p.m.
August 18 "My Two Decades of Writing About Acadia's Founder."
Blue Hill Public Library. 7:00 p.m.
August 19 "Researching and Writing the Early History of ANP."
Seal Harbor Village Improvement Society. 4:00 p.m.?
August 22
Sieur de Monts National Monument Celebration.
"Addresses Upon Its 1916 Opening: Key Readings"
St. Saviours Church. 2:00-4:00 p.m.
August 29 "Writing about Conservation Giants."
Parker Ridge Retirement Community. Blue Hill. 4:30
Viewer Controls
Toggle Page Navigator
P
Toggle Hotspots
H
Toggle Readerview
V
Toggle Search Bar
S
Toggle Viewer Info
I
Toggle Metadata
M
Zoom-In
+
Zoom-Out
-
Re-Center Document
Previous Page
←
Next Page
→
Ellsworths John A Peters Esq and the Father of Acadia Ellsworth PL July 28, 2016
Details
07/28/2016