From a New York paper, May 5, 1887. GEORGE CABOT WARD (1824 1887) George Cabot Ward, who died yesterday, after a long illness, was born in Boston sixty-three years ago. He was the son of Mr. Thomas Wren Ward, who more than seventy years ago came from Boston to this city, and with his relative, the late Jonathan Goodhue, founded the firm of Goodhue and Ward, afterwards so well known as Goodhue & Company. In 1817 he returned to Boston and ten years later became the American agent of Baring Brothers. This agency was exclusively con- ducted by him until his death when it devolved upon his son, Mr. Samuel Gray Ward. George Cabot Ward was graduated at Harvard, and subsequently studied at Heidelberg and after a voyage around the world in a sailing ship, a rare experience in those days, settled in New York and founded the firm of Ward, Campbell & Company. It contained at one time one of the Baring family, but was never, as has been stated, the agent of Baring Brothers. Mr. Ward withdrew from it in 1869 to share with his elder brother, Samuel Gray, who had moved to this city from Boston, the Baring agency, which continued in their hands until George Cabot's illness, when both brothers surrendered it, January, 1885. George Cabot was, when the war broke out, in 1861, one of the most active and energetic supporters of the Government in 2. this city. He was one of the founders of the Union League Club, its president for one term and its Treasurer until the decline of his health. He was also one of the Governors, and, we believe, Treasurer of the New York Hospital, one of the Trustees and most devote and valuable friends of the Children's Aid Society and a director of the Bank of Commerce and of the Union Trust Company. In fact he was one of the men who are always ready "to pay with their person" for any worthy public object, and although of a singularly modest and retiring, and one might almost say self-distrustful disposition, had trusts and respon- sibilities imposed upon him without stint. He was a man of extraordinary simplicity of character and had a rare capacity for devotion to his friends as well as those of the public. His reading was very extensive and his love of speculation in the field of transcendental philosophy often gave an air of quaintness and abstraction to his conversation which made one wonder that a business life in this city should ever have been to his taste. He took a great interest in the establishment of The Nation newspaper in 1865 and perhaps had more to do with putting it on a firm financial footing than any other one person. The mem- ories of the war made him a very good Republican down to his last illness, but in no way diminished his sympathy with all efforts in the direction of purer politics. His death deprives New York of one of her most valuable citizens and one of a type which the existing conditions of business do not foster either in politics or society. Cambridge John Glendening. Letters of Sosiah Royce. Aug. 12, 1887 Dear Dorr: n.of Chicago Press. 1970. PART II 1882-1888 211 I have delayed writing because I wanted to take time to consult a little with my wife the friendly offer that you and your father I have just found the best possible description of my beloved form and mother so kindly made. We have given full consideration to of "memory-hallucination" in the current Archiv fiir Psychiatric.100 the whole matter, and I assure you that we have found the notion a I am as triumphant as you please over it. most attractive one. But there are a number of difficulties in the I hope soon to hear of your continued prosperity. Mrs. Royce way, and my wife feels it necessary to say with much regret that desires to be remembered most warmly to you all. it seems to her impossible to go. She loves the mountains and water Yours Very Truly even more than I do, and thanks you many times for the goodness Josiah Royce. of your plan. Perhaps in some other season such a thing might be just possible.-But the future is its own guardian. In any case don't imagine for a moment that WC underrate your gencrous and con- siderate enthusiasm for our welfare, or the advantages of your To DANIEL Corr GILMAN, FEBRUARY 9, 1888¹ offer. As for your other offer-the bicycle-my wife wants me to 20 Lowell St. try it. She fancies that if I could learn to use it, she would have more Cambridge Feb. 9. 888 respect for me. My reputation for dexterity is not high. Perhaps I My dear Mr. Gilman, might do something, however, and I think I had better try, if you I have joined the too great army of scholarly blunderers who still want mc to. If I succeed, we might arrange for a purchase some break down when they ought to be at their best. The break-down day. If I don't succeed, you must behave as a sewing machine man is nervous of course and needs nothing, I am assured, but a long sea always promises to do, and take it back. Mcanwhile, do you want to voyage all alone, to make me myself again. I don't know when I express it to mc at my expense? If so, I shall regard you with more shall go, but we are now looking for the ship, The College has given admiration than ever. me leave of absence for the rest of the year on half-pay. I feel nearly And now I want to thank you very warmly indeed, and, if all the time very well and nobody meeting me on the strect would possible, your father and your mother yet more warmly still, for a call me ill, but the little devil in the brain is there all the same, and few charming days that I shall certainly never forget. They came this kind goeth not out but by tray clings and hard fare. As you are most opportunely, and at a moment when I especially needed to get the principal cause of my existence in the academic life, I suppose my mind off some harrassing temporary vexations. The result has that you will hear with vexation of my mishap, not to say careless- donc me much good. Your mother seems to mc now a minister of ness. I think that there is no cause for apprehension, and the experi- comfort, pure and simple, and I only regret that in her house I was ence as such is peculiarly edifying, instructive, and even fascinating but a receiver of pleasure, and must have been, especially to her, but to one who loves to study his own mental states. I need hardly add a poor amusement. In future I hope to see much more of you all, at that the expenses of this method of recovering from my troubles times when I am more alive myself. are not furnished from my own savings, but are freely given to me I hope you will remember me to Mr. and Mrs. Wolcott. I ought by a very deaf friend to whom I shall always be deeply indebted. to say to them that in my better moments something in my heart The same kindness insures for me the safety and comfort of my will rise up and say that, after all, a mummy is not a mineral.¹ 105 This family during my absence, and in this entirely unexpected and un- may show I am not wholly hardened. deserved way what would be a very dark path is rendered a very Hodgson must crc this have left you. If not, please say to him that ligly one.- 105 A typed copy of this letter in the Royce Papers contains the following 106 Emil Kracpelin, "Ucber Erinncrungsfälschugen," Archiv fiir Psy- note: "This refers to a discussion raised by him at Oldfarm as to whether a chiatrie 18 (1887): 395 ff. Royce cited these findings in his "Itlucination of mummy might not be termed a mineral, he taking the side, for argument's Memory and "Telepathy'," Mind 13 (1888) 244-48. sake, that it could." 107 ALS. Gilman Papers. JHU. The letter is written in Mrs. Royce's hand. 888 9/20 C.1-1888 notes: Ba Harbor VIA 188B- ? 1. Signatures include C.H. Dorr, not CBD. mores Jesup evolved from 1892, one if Board of Managers. 2. mission "the better regulation of the vill age pertaining to Health, Cleanlinesis, ad Public convenience." (9/20/88). But also "to secure the best resuetts in preseurry H ratural beaut tes of the place "(see p.g 4). 3. as Committee stracture was establish in mid they 1880's, mores Jerup was involved in the Inspection Cannittee as was Mrs. Dorr and YBO on the Water Funt Committee (1888). am HBD suggest estableshart of VIA nursery for shade Arees. (3/11/91) 4. In 1891 sogrif. cant changes in charter- "public mypoments "intended to "ather parts of made "The BHUIA-My receive at hold riol and personal property not excury Fifty thousand dollars in part Inder contract to he binding upon struck but not upon its intrividual method is 5. Contriving involvement Thes Our. BHVIA. 2 Commette structure Finance, Entertuente, Savitay, Road Pather, Treat Plantings. Each detribed (pp. 107ff, 1891) a of 1894, Mrs. Dor is Chair of Comm. entress, George on foods + Paths Ires along c North back beatrix Jones on both. July, 1895 minute , Path Comm. calls attention to "the work done y un. George Dou on the road idea and contrast & arth the horrible eyesores with which our [eyes are ] met on most of the roads m the island." Stress dris for guring of readsides Sept. 1895 Inmute received An GBD, chairm of the Aprist Committee m biggle path, a repat raturd as whole. note: anph 200 refere to "Seventh an neal maily of the BU VIA; 7/21/96. a 1896 marty Urs doer is in Nominating canmifa inclusin m Bond of managers. she of Gurge are in this groy. also Weir Mitchell & M. Jump. more un devel of Dorr/Goos cellaborative Caderalader parts Go. main 1641 BHUIA-3 Don is on of 3 member of a new comntte "to connect +advise I with the Brand of Health" a the "thorough sanitary renovation of such posting the Village f Bit."as Du consulter byo to then attemh. for the present epidenic "to "proceen expect assistance." 1897 mes. Daris report ) of Committee a Trees given (09.227). CBD, 7.7. Smith, M.D., & S Weir nitchell are the 1897 Sanitation Commettee. Mrs. Cadwalader Jones Mrs. on Village (monthle - report, 1897. George Dan 1897 report on forgete Path (fos.243). Miss feating Jones appear on 1898 list of pond of managero- also for Lowever for 1899-1900 Mrs. Charles Does still Chairs Comm on Trees and is mabulf Entertainment Cream Rev. houre continue invalvest. BHUIA-4 Length July 1901 repat by 6BD if Wnh done 8 Tree and Road-fide Committee. Gp.288 H.D. God example of Davis detail, ad writing style, ad prinities. what follows (291 +f. ) is another 2 page Biggle Path amattee Super report. Clear to me that GBD is the main agent of these efforts. Buycle Path ad newport mountain Road Committee superceder Boughter Path Committee, 1901. note In 1987 Mrs. Darr solonger Charris n is a committee must but still Board of Manager member. George still a Road, & Pathe Comm, of notice may to ownership by BHUIA of town land (v.2.pg2)) notice of death Mrs Chack Does (p.g.33) Sept. 29, 1902, also posted id' B.H.Record achievelys her as me of original in corporation in 1888 Refer he be probility to that sunnet pg. Harvard Univ. Archives 10.9.02 HUG 300 Pup Coll. Scl. Grad. Div. Law Med. Den. Yet. Bus. Hon. B3391 BORN Dorr, George Bucknam 74-g-hon DIED 29 Dec 1853 at Boston, mass COLLEGE SCIENTIFIC GRADUATE DIVINITY LAW MEDICAL august DENTAL VETERINARY 1944 at BUSSEY Bar Marbor Hon 8/44 maine 1888-89 1870-771 1889-90 per etipping BIR. 4871-722 1890-91 1872-733 1873-7414 AB 1874 SB AM a STB LLB MD DMD MDV BAS A.M. 1923 OCCUPATION S.M.(1oo.) Univ. Maine 1924 p 3/29 Dov - Lit DATE RESIDENCE DATE BUSINESS ADDRESS Ball '36, Bar Harbor Maine p3/09 Somerost Clean 42 Beacan St. 1913 18 to results walth unses, see 1/34 Boston +1 mass H.F.C.5/40 Old Farm Bar- Harbor, maine Son of Charles Hagen Dorr and mary Gray PATENTED Ward. MAY 28, 1897 LIBRARY BUREAU 02880 , Note: G.BP. listed as graduate student. in chemistry and mathematics No evidence he attended classes or received grades. TIMES: pg loft UGUST 13, 1919 FIVE CENTS A COPY NUMBER 267 SUMMER CABARET MORRELL PARK DEDICATION CLUB GAVE SHOW EXERCISES HELD ON FRIDAY ableaux Vivants Given Before Ap- preciative Audience Tues- day Evening The first of the Tuesday evening Eloquent and Sincere Tributes To the Late Gen- Intertainments of the Summer Cabaret Club was staged at the Swimming Club in Tuesday evening before a. large au- eral Edward Morrell by Judge Deasy, lience that greatly appreciated; the per- ormance of the Tableaux Vivants, Hon. Bourke Cochran, T. DeWitt y local talent The entertainment vas arranged by Mrs. William Lawrence Green and posed by Ernest de Weerth. Cuyler and Bishop Walsh The careful coloring and the tasteful etting of the pieces added much to the race of the poses. Next Tuesday the Cabaret Club will Unfortunately the rain of Thursday Judge Deasy's Address resent another series of tableaux of a afternoon made it necessary to postpone ittle different order entitled, A Club- Judge Deasy in opening the meeting the dedication of Morrell Park and the said: nan's Remembrances of the Past. The unveiling of the tablet to the memory Ladies and Gentlemen following week a short play will be of the late General Edward Morrell. It is my duty and my pleasure to call presented. The exercises were held Friday morning, this informal and rather small morling In the tableaux Tuesday night Miss with but a small number of persons in to order. If yesterday had been aun Sheila Byrne was the Girl in the Moon, attendance compared to those who would shiny it would have still been informal represented seated on a crescent with a have gathered at the park had the but a much larger meeting My duty large, looking owl. The tableaux weather man been more kind Thursday. is to call the meeting to order and to with its artistic lighting effects was most However, there were a considerable state briefly its purpose and to present triking. Miss Strange as Girl's Head number of friends and admirers of the to you a gentleman who will, in fitting nd Miss Adee The Coquette repre- distinguished late summer resident of words, dedicate this Park to the per ented well-known paintings. The Girl Bar Harbor. The exercises were most petual use of the people and this mem with Dove was the fine representation appropriate and the tributes to General morial to the memory of a man to a painting by Greuze by Miss Eliza- Morrell fell upon the ears of a sympathet- whose foresight and public spirit this eth Caswell and Miss Zell. Carmencita ic audience, an audience almost all of memorial, this benefaction 18 primary and the Spanish Lady were in typical whom knew and appreciated the many due. Spanish costume by Miss Maizie Stewart excellent qualities of the late General I have been a resident of Bar Harbor and Miss Lelia Emery. Madame But- Morrell. for more than thirty years. When erfly was portrayed in a delightful Judge Deasy opened the meeting and came here the only things on the island 1880's nanner by Miss Hannah Wright. She his tribute to General Morrell and to of Mt. Desert that were dedicated vas represented as looking from the Mrs. Morrell was that of a leading citizen public use, that were free to the user of window for the return of her lover. of Bar Harbor, a man who could best the public, were some very dirty and The Image Seller was a striking pose voice the appreciation of the citizens muddy roads The people could either y Miss Rosalie Bloodgood and Philip of the town. Judge Deasy then intro- walk the streets or 80 home The beauty Plant. The Fortune Teller was a duced Bishop Walsh of Portland, who of Mt. Desert had been appreciated antasie by Miss Susie Stewart as the unveiled the memorial tablet and pre- before that had been written up in hypsy in typical costume and Miss Zell sented the deed of the Park to the the magazines and artists had come here LS the subject. trustees. The Bishop's address was to portray on canvas its wondrous Miss Bohlen as the Twenty-first more than an eloquent tribute to the charm and beauty but in those days Century Girl was a rather amusing memory of General Morrell. It was no man. woman or child had a right to Dept characterization of what fashion may rich in historical reference and in appre- stand in any place or mit in any place e expected to accomplish in another ciation of the Mt. Desert Island that outside their own home and view three hundred years. In designing the cos- the general loved 80 well. lovely beauties, because nobody has a ume, all of the present day fads were Thomas DeWitt-Cuyler, a life-long right to stand or sit in the public atreals arried to an extreme with a result that friend of General Morrell and chairman to view the scenery The atreets are was rather startling. of the board of trustees for the park, made for UN to move on, and in this was the next speaker. In a few brief age of automobiles it is said that the The main piece of the evening was a remarks Mr. Cuyler paid his tribute to pedestrians in the public streets air arge tableaux with eight characters, his friend and accepted the deed of the divided classen the The Pearl of Asia taken from a French lands. The Hon Bourke Cochran WHA the dead But picture. The characters were artistically in the audience and Judge Deasy asked Bar Harbor has acquired several portrayed by Miss Eno, Miss Audrey him if he would not make afew remarks resting places for the public and Emery, Miss Rhinelander, Miss Maupin, Mr. Cochran is an orator of note and the last few months these Miss Fenno, Miss Ingalls, Miss Caroline has been heard on weveral occasions here have been made M Public National DuBois and Mr. Bates. but his extemploraneous remarks of There are some people who The songs between the pictures by Friday morning were as fine HM anything travel over the mountains but this Mr. Train and Miss Zell added much that a local audience has heard. Mr. the privilege of only a few to the success of the evening. Cochran was in Congress with General others of UN who do not Morrell and knew him well. He spoke climbing as 24 regular The program was: of the General's unselfishness and of his will not may to which class I below The Girl in the Moon desire to give of himself as well HN of who are either too old or A fantasie his fortune to many people here and lame or too fat. or laxy Miss SHBILA BYRNE elsewhere. climbing But here Song Those on the platform were: Judge charm and beauty all MR. TRAIN Dearry, Bishop Walsh, Rev. Fr. Brien, accessible Thomas DeWitt Cuyler, Fred C. Lynam public which (CONTINUED ON PAGE 8) and Thomas Searls. The exercises were which the simple but most impressive. Extracts close Here from the remarks of the speakers follow 199-2011 Page 3 [BarHarbor Times. 8/13/19] THE BARJ HAT BOB TIMES WEDNESI MORRELL PARK DEDICATION Bishop Walsh's Address the soul and vision of this great knight EXERCISES HELD ON FRIDAY Bishop Walsh's address follows: You will not take it amias it. should (CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1) Mr. Chairman, Honorable Board of suggest how fittingly the great National come, surrounded by these hills (whether Trustees and Select Friends who have Park at Mt. Dewert might have been live can see them or not) (foggy) and come to honor this occasion: called Champlain Park, for while all teiving from them wireless méssages I love to think of the State of Maine due credit ought to, go to De Monta, of rest and peace and tranquility and as the real Eden or Summer l'aradise who (bought and sold the charter, but health and hope and faith And there of North America. never put a foot upon this shore, and was a man of vision who saw the wonder- Where indeed will be found the glories to Lafayette, symbol of noble France, ful potentialities of this place, who felt of God's creation in the physical order that forced England to make us, a free that it should be devoted to the public more varied and imposing? people, yet to Champlain belongs the who acquired. the property and while If, as the royal psalmist says: "the higher honor and greater memorial. he did not himself give it to be devoted heavens tell of the glory of God" well Many others have come to Mount to the free use of the public, he conceived may the same be truly said of the lakes Desert and haye shown a fine spirit of the idea that man of public spirit and streams, the hills and valleys, the generosity and sacrifice to bring out the was Edward Morrell. And there is fertile ffields from the Allegash to the natural beauty of this Eden, by most a woman of like vision altruism and Saco, and even more of the rocky cliffs, artistic houses, admirable garden, costly public spirit, nay greater because deep white sands and islands innumerable, roads, not alone for their own comfort ened by love and devotion, and the of its great coast line or seashore, the and pride, Equite legitimate though that dedication of this beautiful park is: due unsurpassed Riviera of Maine. be, but also to give to all corners the particularly to her. Louise Drexel Mor- If the thought and prayer of the sense of appreciating the true, the good rell. Some few months ago she gave psalmist shall ever slip away or be per- and the beautiful in every form at over to the Trustees for the benefit of manently obscured in the mind of the tractive to the human eye. the public this part of the park imme- people and the masses come to follow Wealth and personal interest are finely diately surrounding it, about twenty the teaching of the infidel intellectuals, symbolized all over this Island by men or twenty-five acres. and today the rest, that all this creation is only the chance and families, that have come from far some sixty or seventy acres in all, will product of blind finite forces, rather than and near to honor and glorify Mount be transferred to the Trustees, who are the work of God, then the destroying Desert and Maine. las follows: Thomas DeWitt Cuyler, hand of man will make greater havoc Their names are known to all students chairman, Fred C. Lynam, Rev. Fr. than earthquake or volcano. or readers of Bar Harbor history, but O'Brien, Thomas Searls and Charles In Maine it is not permitted to doubt, I would have them known to every child H. Wood. The succession of trustee- that the island on which we now stand, in and of Bar Harbor, taught in every ship is provided so that when a vacancy is the most beautiful corner of the school geography and history as one of will occur, one trustee is selected by the garden, for here all the great features the chief lessons, told in simple story or Kebo Valley Club, one by the Trustèes seem concentrated or crystallized before inspiring rhythmic verse, to stand forth of the Jesup Memorial Library, one by our wondering eyes, valley and mountain, as the 'Maker's of Bar Harbor" just as the Roman Catholic Bishop of Portland woodland and field, cliff and sand beach, precious for our age as the "Makers of and two by the Selectmen of the Town fog and bracing air; while the ocean is Venice" for Ruskin, the "Makers of of Bar Harbor, and we are met here ever singing its song of triumph or Florence" for Oliphant, or the "Maker today to dedicate this monument. But saluting in rythmic waves the Isle of the of England" by any Poet Laureate. the monument that we are to dedicate barren mountains, God speaking to Of one such maker, benefactor and is not this huge rock nor the bronze man by the voice of the silent rock, knight of Bar Harbor it is my honor to tablet upon it. The monument we are mountain, valley "and shore. speak brief words of praise today. In to dedicate is this Park with all its charm Our Island, by and because of these the name of his lady consort and be- and beauty. But it is more than that- great free gifts, to all comers, attracts reaved widow I here and now unveil the most important part of the monu- all classes; the artist to seek the inspira- this massive granite boulder and bronze ment is the instrument itself by which tion that will permit him to copy Nature's tablet thereon and give over the Deed this Park is given over to public use. models upon canvass, stone or bronze; to the Honorable Board of Trustees, to I do not propose to read the instrument the young and vigorous to get the proclaim to all the people of Bar Harbor, but I propose to read which is strength and endurance needed for the that he lived for the good of all the people, characteristic of it, "It is the desire of battles of life; the feeble and aged to that he shared cheerfully all his treasures the grantor that the Trustees may never find the repose for the tired or closing with them whilst living amongst them deem it it desirable to post notices to eye, without stopping the fretful heart; and that he wished for their use and 'Keep Off the Grass'. (Applause). rest, air, peace, how truly are they the ownership in perpetuity this fine Park I think that if Edward Morrell had him- life-giving riverlets in every nook and and wonderful natural/ emphitheatre, self dictated this document he might corner of this Island Beautiful! wherein may be found the very best in have used a little different language. Above and beyond all these glorious air, sky, mountain, woodland, thus He would have said, "The Trustees are features there comes to me today the every good upbuilding factor in recrea- ordered and directed to post notices historic white man to encircle these tion that adorns the greatest cities of reading 'Get Onto the Grass." (Ap- shores, to give to the island its. pic- the world at great expense, however, plause), for Edward Morrell was a man, turesque name, and, three years before to the 'people themselves. I need not, as I knew him and as many (of Gorges at Popham (1607) sixteen years but will, name my knight and benefactor, you people knew him, who would not before Bradford at Plymouth (1620), the late Col. Edward deV. Morrell, of enjoy standing on the grass himself the first, in fact, to make the history of Bar Harbor and Philadelphia. unless all the people could have the right New France and New England, and by He was a man of the classes and of or privilege of standing on the grass with his maps and descriptions of this island the masses, if such distinction be allowed him. (Applause.) and the entire coast of Maine, to fashion in a safe and sane democracy. I present to you the Bishop of Port- and bind together the first links of New English and French blood mixed to land; Bishop Walsh, the head of the England's golden chain of great things make him the man, the gentleman, the Roman Catholic Church of Maine, the and great men. nobleman that we hope is and is to be church of which Edward Morrell was When will the poet rise to interpret finer than either of those races, the a devoted son and Louise Drexel Morrell typical American gentleman and noble- loving daughter present Rishon man and the Catholic faith was the sap Walsh, a man who enjoys in the highest that vivilied mind, heart and dogree the esteem, respect and love, not only of his own people, the people of his church, but all people of the State of Maine in which he lives and which he honors,-Bishop Walsh. 21 Harvard philosopher Josiah Royce dedicates his Spirit of Modern Philosophy : An Essay in the form of a Lecture to Mary Gray Ward Dorr, mother of George Bucknam Dorr. The narrative was based on an social arrangement initiated by Mrs. Dorr prior to Royce's composition of these 1889-1890 lectures delivered at gatherings that she arranged. In 1890-91 the content was reconstituted for delivery at Harvard prior to its 1892 publication in Boston by Houghton Mifflin Company. This is reputed to be the first occasion when a philosophical book was dedicated to a member of the opposite sex. See Royce file for additional content. TO MY FRIEND Mary Gray CHard Dorr I GRATEFULLY DEDICATE THIS BOOK AS A TOKEN OF AFFECTION AND VENERATION IN RECOGNITION OF THE WISE COUNSEL THAT SUGGESTED ITS PREPARATION AND OF THE THOUGHTFUL ADVICE THAT ACCOMPANIED AND AIDED ITS GROWTH L.J.R. John Clendenning Ed. Letters of Josiah Royee LL. Chicago, 1970. lof3 232 PART III 1888-1900 PART III 1888-1900 233 have been more humane, or more magnanimous in a true sense.-I for a whole month, that, were I not too greedy of a good rest to regret, of course (just because she must have regretted it), that she restrain myself, I no doubt ought to make the time shorter. But, as had to confess the harmless and even praiseworthy weakness of it is I shall hope, with your assent, to appear as near August ist as getting momentarily out of patience with poor mc. Nobody de- proves to be possible, giving you due notice of the precise time as it serves it more than I. I haven't been an odious little creature all approaches. You do not know how much good your kindness will these years without fully knowing the fact, and I think of none SO do me. 13.1 highly as I do of those who share my appreciation of the odiousness With warmest regards to all, I remain in question. Please treasure up this fact to impart it to all who Yours very truly, declare, as some will do, that I am not only odious, but vain-glori- Josiah Royce. ous. Doubtless I am, but not save as Satan dwells in me. Well, as said, the hurricane subsides, the wind becomes a zephyr, and the trees still stand. Fox's glory is still untarnished, and his letter is a model. As for mc, I have written no word on Loisettc yet, To GEORGE HOLMES HOWISON, JULY 13, 1889 nor could I put pen on paper once last evening. The only thing about me that is unsubdued is and shall be my appetite for food. 20 Lowell St. Yours Ever Cambridge, Mass. Josiah Royce. July 13, 1889. Dear Mr. Howison:- I am much pleased to hear of the Constitution of your Philo- sophical Union, and to be able to recognize amongst its members To MARY GRAY WARD DORR, JUNE 21, 188911 several of my former friends and students. I am deeply grateful for the honor conferred upon me by my election as a Corresponding 20 Lowell Street Member. I have not yet received the Secretary's Letter, but of Cambridge, Mass. course I shall at once accept the offered position, and shall be very June 21st, 1889 glad if at any time in future I can be of direct or indirect service to Dear Mrs. Dorr, the Union. Please always count on me. I have delayed my answer to your very kind letter of Sunday in During the past academic year I have managed to keep very order to consult with my wife as to the possibility of her accepting much my old health, and have had a fairly successful time. I have your invitation to stay with you at Bar Harbor. She feels very been especially gratified at the growth of the Graduate work grateful for it, and has been trying hard to plan SO as to go; but amongst us. I have given a course on Kant's Kritik, read in the after fullest consideration we have decided that so good a thing original, to seven graduates from both our own and other institu- may not now be. The new house on Irving Street which is build- tions, and have been delighted to deal at last with men who were ing for us [sic] unites with various complications suggested by the fairly free in their German, and who would read an article on Kant three children to exclude the possibility of her going, either with in German without whining and without the dictionary. All my the baby, or without. As for me alone, however, I am free, or at men were, as graduate students, aiming at the academic life, and at least still may hope to be so, for as much as a month. You offer me least three of them have already good prospects as academic "all of August." I hope I shall not be rating my poor presence for teachers of philosophy. So, as you see, even we progress. During too much if I venture, in advance, to accept for that time, or a few the coming year I am to give a graduate course on Hegel's Phä- days less, as fortune may determine. You are SO kind in asking me nomenologie, once more of course using the original. In fact das 11 TLC. Royce Papers. HUA. 12 ALS. Howison Papers. UCB. L.J.R. John Clendenning Ed. fetters of Josiah Roger. uchicago. 1970 2of3 240 PART III 1888-1900 PART III 1888-1900 241 the family of the teacher himself, in whose house you then board before Christmas in Boston. And there is in any case little to dread along with two, three, or four other students; and the larger private in cold weather. schools, where you are one of a class, and meet many boys. Both plans have their special advantages. The household tutoring of the first class mentioned is the best, if you want the most rapid advance possible in your studies as such, and if you desire the constant per- To MARY GRAY WARD DORR, OCTOBER 31, 188918 sonal advice of a teacher. The other plan, the large school (pref- erably the boarding school) is the best for acquiring a knowledge Irving Street, Cambridge of the society about you, for getting the discipline of life, and for October 31, 1889 cultivating a healthy spirit of emulation in good things. The first of My dear Mrs. Dorr, the two plans is of course the more expensive. The very best I have seen Mrs. Whitman, and for the moment, as I understand teachers are thus employed in receiving boys into their families in the matter, the plan for the lectures appears in the following pro- small groups, and devoting all their time to these few boys. But the visional form: the twelve lectures are to be given one per week, best schools are also very good, though not quite equal as mere probably on Tuesday afternoons, beginning early in December, places of study, to the houses of private tutors. always providing, of course, that my kind clients desire to have If I were to advise you for the immediate future, I should say them given at all. The subject proposed would be: "Some Note- that, in case you can afford the expense, the first year, say this worthy Persons and Doctrines in the History of Modern Thought." coming winter might very well be passed in receiving private I should sketch the persons and characters of half a dozen thinkers, instruction under an expert teacher in his own house, along with a more or fewer, as say Spinoza, Leibnitz, Berkeley, Kant, Fichte, few other boys. This one winter, I say, that plan comparatively Hegel, Schopenhauer. I should give some idea, not of the technical expensive though it might prove, would be the very best, because details of their systems, but of their personal attitude towards the thus you would most readily get over the first difficulties of your world, towards the ideals of life, and towards God. Then I should change of place and of studies, and would be sure of the best care of try to characterize some of the problems of modern life and phi- your health during your first Eastern winter. Then it would be well losophy, as determined, in a measure, by these very thinkers. In and easy to choose a good private school to finish your preparation conclusion, I should try to suggest something of my own attitude. in. I am sure that I could make a good arrangement of this sort for How would that do? you. As I believe that I told you, my own family is now too large I hope you won't find me a failure. I am a very much beset man for me to take you as a lodger into my own house, but I should be at present as to the uncomfortable tasks of cares of life, and am glad to have you near mc, and to give you whatever care I can. likely to be much overworked before winter is over. This task, Don't regard it as necessary, however, for you to adopt this plan however, would be to me both a delight and a rest, at any rate if as to the private teaching if you come. I can easily find you a good you approved the outcome. place to board and then have you go to the High School, which, Yours very truly, as I told you, is a very good school of its kind, here in Cambridge. Josiah Royce. Whatever you decide, count on my readiness to advise and assist. Remember me affectionately to your father and mother, and believe me Yours Always 18 TLC. Royce Papers. HUA. This and the succeeding letter to Mrs. Josiah Royce. Dorr are concerned with Royce's series of lectures on "Some Prominent I have mentioned your health during the first winter. I have very Men, Issues and Tendencies in the History of Modern Philosophy." The twelve lectures were given during the winter of 1889-90; later expanded and little fear about that however. There is seldom any severe cold rewritten, they were read twice in 1890 and finally published as SMP. L.J.R. John Clendening. Ed felters of Jostah Royse u. Chicago, 1970. 30F3. 242 PART III 1888-1900 PART III 1888-1900 243 To MARY GRAY DORR, DECEMBER 19, 188919 To ROBERT UNDERWOOD JOHNSON, JUNE 4, 189020 103 Irving St., Cambridge 103 Irving Street December 19, 1889 Cambridge My dear Mrs. Dorr, June 4, 1890 I await, with some eagerness, such criticisms (the more negative Mr. R. U. Johnson: the better, so long as they express the opinion of any note-worthy person) upon my first lecture as shall enable me to get nearer to my Dear Sir- audience in future. At present we-my audience and I-arc rather I enclose notes on the interesting article by Mr. Fitch. The far apart in spirit; at least I feel so, and that in part by my own often told story of the Congressional Debates over the Ad- fault. I don't write in any spirit of discouragement, for it was a mission of California has suggested to me, in Mr. Fitch's version, very kindly and delightful audience, and I am sure that I shall yet no comments, although it is possible that in such time as I have hit much nearer home, but just now my feeling is, from what I can given to the paper, I have overlooked minor errors. The contro- gather, that the affair on Tuesday was indeed a reasonably innocent verted points in the earlier part of the paper have, on the contrary, beginning, but that I didn't quite convey as much as I wanted to. I led me to make, very possibly, fuller notes than you desired. I have was too afraid of being dull, apologized too much for philosophy, even taken the risk of troubling you with a previously unpublished made too long a preliminary, quoted too many poets, confused some document, of recent date, but of good origin, bearing on the leg- hearers with excess of illustration, and others by lack of salient endary "race" of Sloat and Seymour.22 I hope, by the way, that points, and in short did not do SO well as I shall try to do hereafter. the numerous legends of the conquest, about that race, about the This I learn not from inner consciousness but from friendly criti- Bear Flag, and the rest, will either be given you somewhat spar- cism. I am now preparing number two. I shall try to be more simple, ingly, or else will come in such shape as to admit of easy reduction direct, organic in structure of lecture, &c. To this end I shall wel- to their foundation of fact (such as it is). For if you have to give come criticism from you and George, and that with the frankest attention to them all in such measure as they usually desire, I can good will and gratitude. The whole affair is an experiment, which only offer my sympathy for the vexation that they will cause you pleases me much, but which I shall have to modify much as I carry before they get through your hands. Beware, I should say to any it out. Won't you aid me with a suggestion or two? fellow-student of those days, beware old Frémont's withered Yours truly branch, beware the awful avalanche of yarns that the Sloat family, Josiah Royce. I am in the best of spirits and health. I write as I do because I 20 ALS. Johnson Papers. UCB. This and several succeeding letters to really want suggestions for practical use. Johnson are concerned with a series of Century publications on California history. Royce assisted Johnson as contributor, editor, and general consultant. 21 George Hamlin Fitch, "How California Came into the Union," Century Magazine 40 (September 1890) 775-92. Fitch's article is printed with notes, signed "Editor," but probably written by Royce. 22 This document was presumably a letter to Royce from Sir Clements Robert Markham, who, remembering his service on the Collingwood in 1846, asserts that there was no race and that the English had no plans to scize California. Parts of this letter, together with parts of a letter to Mark- ham from Admiral Lord Alcester (also on the Collingwood) were published in Royce's "Light on the Seizure of California," Century Magazine 40 (Sep- 19 TLC. Royce Papers. HUA. tember 1890), 792-94. See fn. 73, Part II above. 17 ion, appeared in 1888 and other stories," ' The Long Exile and other stories for children, Family 1 behalf of the new system, Happiness, The Cossacks,' a new translation of & War and Peace, all ated by actual voting with from the Russian of Count Tolstoi (who has been pleased to express wrote a letter to the Board his satisfaction with them); and many others, including translations ing athletics at Cambridge, from the French and Spanish, and a number of Goethe's minor works ae Overseers. (See Boston for the Barrie edition. I gave, in the spring of 1887, a course of six i, 1889, delivered an address lectures on Russian Literature in Philadelphia and Germantown: rewrote leveland," at Baltimore, Md. ; them and gave them in the Berkeley Lyceum Theatre, New York City, cle entitled Substitutes for in the spring of 1888. I also lectured in Deerfield, Mass., before the house at Manchester, Mass., ' Summer School of History and Romance' (in 1887), and in Brooklyn ew home, 113 Brattle Street, on Tolstoi. Is married and has two children : Robert Montgomery, born Sept. 29, 1884, and his born June 13, 1884, and Arthur Alexander, March 14, 1886. Office in Still practises law and man- Boston is with T. Y. Crowell & Co., 65 Kingston Street. GEORGE BUCKNAM DORR. Has entered no profession or business since graduation; has travelled change, and of the firm of much in Europe and in this country, but has been at his home in Boston okers, 4 Post-Office Square, most of the time of late, spending his summers at Bar Harbor, Mt. tree children. Resides at 367 Desert, Me. Resides at 18 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston, Mass. JAMES DWIGHT. On account of poor health, practice of medicine has been inter ., Aug. 7, 1881. rupted is still actively interested in tennis. Was married Jan. 12, p. 16, 17. 1887, to Elizabeth Iasigi; has one child, Dorothy, born July 15, 1888. Resides at 225 Beacon Street, Boston. the staff of the Philadelphia LOUIS DYER. d to take editorial charge of Remained in Cambridge as Assistant Professor of Greek and Latin founded by one of the Selig- until June, 1887, when his resignation took effect. In September follow- g, but it proved anything but using side. This connection ing, he went abroad, intending to be-absent about a year. (No report since 1887.) spending the summer pleas to enter the employ of the WILLIAM SAMUEL ELIOT. as general literary adviser, offer to remain in New York Died in Boston, Mass., Nov. 15, 1874. 1 the former, and have since See Secretary's Report No. 2 (1877), pp. 17, 18. built a small house on Glen Hedgecote.' I have been JOHN WHEELOCK ELLIOT. since the beginning of 1886 Has continued to practise medicine in Boston, having his office at his Enoch when probably trans- residence, 75 Marlborough Street. In 1886 was appointed surgeon to hore remunerative. Here is out-patients at the Massachusetts General Hospital. Has published Ivan Ityitch and other articles in Wood's Handbook of Medical Science," and in the "Bos- A Russian Proprietor and ton Medical and Surgical Journal." Is married. 8/14/2018 Catalog Record: Sixty years of the Union Boat Club I Hathi Trust Digital Library Home About Collections Help Feedback 1911 FULL-TEXT CATALOG Search words about the items All Fields Advanced catalog search Search tips Full view only Cite this Similar Items Export citation file Sixty years of the Union Boat Club / By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- C.B.D. listed as correct member, beganning Si) 1960. in 1889. the Published: (1913) The Arthur of the English Cl poets. clu By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- 1960 list Published: (1969) The Arthur of the English SIXTY YEARS an poets, im By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- of 1960. OF THE Published: (1969) 18 The Arthur of the English UNION BOAT CLUB CO poets / By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- se 1960 Published: (1966) BY Mai The Arthur of the English poets / THE CLUB HISTORIAN By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- F 1960. N Published: (1907) The wife of Bath's tale; its Lan sources and analogues, Pu By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- 1960. Published: (1901) The wife of Bath's tale: its sources and analogues. S By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- 1960. Published: (1972) The first American novelist? By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- A LIST OF MEMBERS 1960. Published: (1940) AND The works of Henry Fielding with the author's preface THE MORE IMPORTANT RACES OF THE CLUB By: Fielding, Henry, 1707-1754 FROM 1851 TO 1911 Published: (1918) P The works of Daniel Defoe / Des By: Defoe, Daniel, 1661?-1731. COMPILED BY Published: (1903) THE SECRETARY L Justa me V Vie G. Maynadier Full Han BOSTON PRINTED FOR THE UNION BOAT CLUB Added: 8/14/18 President Harrison's Visit in 1889 by Gladys O'Neil President Harrison on board the steamer Sappho The people of Bar Harbor, indeed flowers. The President was SO impressed Harbor Band played as the President those of the entire island of Mt. with the scenery as they sailed across came ashore and stepped into a car- Desert, were looking forward to the the bay that he spent the entire trip near riage for the drive to Stanwood, Mr. arrival of President Harrison on August the bow of the ship on the upper deck. Blaine's summer cottage on Cleftstone 7th in 1889. It would be the second At the wharf in Bar Harbor even Road, where he would be a guest dur- time in the history of the town that a larger crowds were gathered to greet ing his week at Bar Harbor. The streets President had come for a visit. Presi- were lined with people hoping to get a dent Arthur had come for a short stay glimpse of him as he rode by. in the Fall of 1882 and President Grant The President was so As might be expected, many par- had planned to come in 1887, but his impressed with the scenery ties and events were planned to enter- ship became fogbound below Rockland tain President Harrison during his and he returned to Washington. A as they sailed across the visit. The first of these was a trip on good-sized crowd was waiting at the the Sappho to Somes Sound. The sev- Mt. Desert Ferry when the train, its bay that he spent the entire enty-five guests on board enjoyed a engine covered with flags and stream- trip near the bow of the delicious lunch prepared by Sproul's ers, arrived with the President on Restaurant. The trip was a little rough board. He was greeted by his Secretary ship on the upper deck. and the President returned to Bar Har- of State, James Blaine, and Henry bor by carriage from Somesville. Cabot Lodge who had come from Bar A garden party was given by Harbor on the steamer Sappho, which the Chief Executive. As the Sappho Major and Mrs. Aulick Palmer at their had made a special trip to meet the approached, a twenty-one gun salute cottage at Otter Cliffs. Two hundred presidential party. Cheers rose from was fired by the U.S. Revenue Cutter and fifty people were served a lun- the spectators as the President boarded Woodbury, and many flag-bedecked cheon outdoors as the Bar Harbor the steamer, which was well-decorated yachts in the harbor joined in the Band played. An elaborate reception with bunting and its salons filled with salute by blowing whistles. The Bar was held at the Kebo Valley Club, continued on page 13 13 HARRISON continued from page 10 Corporate Sponsors STORM A BOOKLOVER'S HAVEN MAIN STREET, ROUTE 102 SOMESVILLE, MAINE 04660 TELEPHONE: 244-4114 TOLL FREE: 800-694-4114 We take the time to build relationships that build value. BAR HARBOR BANKING AND TRUST COMPANY The steamer Sappho, circa 1800 where nearly five hundred guests were down to Mt. Desert Street, Maine presented to the President before they Street and across Cottage Street. The danced the night away in the ball- procession was a pretty sight as it room. This event was described as passed the club house from where it Duffy's one of the most brilliant affairs that was viewed by the presidential party. Quarterdeck Bar Harbor had ever seen. The last party for President Har- On the afternoon of August 13 a rison was a dinner followed by a musi- Restaurant Flower Parade was held for the Presi- cal program given by Mr. and Mrs. 1 Main Street dent. Mrs. Burton Harrison, summer Walter Gurnee at Beau Desert. The Bar Harbor, ME 288-5292 resident and author, was in charge of most prominent members of the sum- the arrangements for the event. Long mer colony were among the invited A restaurant of distinction before the band played "Hail to the guests. The President left Bar Harbor dedicated to fine food and Chief," announcing the arrival of the excellent service the next morning, August 14. President with Mr. Blaine, crowds had Thus ended one of the most already filled the Kebo Valley Club exciting and interesting weeks that the grounds. Thirty-one flower-covered town had ever experienced. carriages were to drive around the Printed with permission of Acadia track several times and then proceed Publishing Co. RESOURCE SENSITIVE SUGGESTION Asticou Inn. Northeast Harbor, Maine 04662 Leave No Butts 800 258-3373 207 276-3344 We all are familiar with the "leave no trace" policy in our wilderness areas and parks nationwide. This applies to cigarette butts as well. Carelessly MDI Business Systems tossing a cigarette butt on the ground is littering. Did you know that it takes Rte. 3 Bar Harbor approximately 3-5 years for a filtered cigarette butt to decompose? Also, 58% P.O. Box 39 Salsbury Cove, Maine 04672 of Acadia's fires are smoking related. 1-800-659-4MDI Acadia's forests are quite dry from the exposure to salt air, and sparks 207-288-2301 can catch quickly. Please avoid smoking in forested areas. Help us maintain IBM & Compatible Computers Xerox Copiers a quality experience for everyone. If you must pack in cigarettes, pack out XEROX the butts. Haths Tust Report of the President of Harvs & College 9/23/13 1889-92, Ca broda 11 From Francis G. Peabody, $100, for the class-room library in the Ethics of the Social Questions." From Albert Bushnell Hart, $28.02, for the working library of books on American History and Politics. From Carleton Hunneman, $3, for the German class-room library. From an anonymous giver, $5, without restrictions. The total amount of these gifts for immediate use is $162,225.49, as is also stated on page 18 of this report. Also: OTHER GIFTS ACKNOWLEDGED BY THE CORPORATION. GBO Sr, $115K. From Henry L. Higginson, a tract of land in Brighton income 15.7K. containing about twenty-one acres of upland and ten acres of marsh, to be called " The Soldier's Field," and used for the present as a playground for the students. From Mrs. Elizabeth C. Ware and Miss Mary L. Ware, the offer of a collection of glass models of plants, flowers, and analytical details of vegetable structure, now in process of construction by Leopold and Rudolf Blaschka, of Ger- many, and provision for their proper exhibition in the Uni- versity Museum, "as a memorial of the late Dr. Charles Eliot Ware, of the Class of 1834." From Mrs. George von L. Meyer, the wrought-iron work for the Johnston gate-way at the main entrance to the College Yard. From the Thomson-Houston Electric Co., an electric motor with its attachments, for the Jefferson Physical Laboratory. From George B. Dorr, two engravings of the Coliseum, by Piranesi, for the library of the Jefferson Physical Laboratory. From Radtke, Lauckner & Co., of New York, six proofs of modern etchings to be added to the Gray Collection of Engravings. By the bequest of William T. Carleton, his copy of a por- trait of Galileo, for the Observatory. From a committee of the Class of 1846, a portrait of George Frisbie Hoar. From Richard S. Greenough, his bust in bronze of the historian George Bancroft. Digitized by Google Original from UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN 8/14/2018 Catalog Record: Sixty years of the Union Boat Club I Hathi Trust Digital Library Home About Collections Help Feedback 1889 FULL-TEXT CATALOG Search words about the items All Fields Advanced catalog search Search tips Full view only Cite this Similar Items Export citation file Sixty years of the Union Boat Club / By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- G.B.D. listed as current member, originalf Si) 1960. began membershap in 1889. the Published: (1913) The Arthur of the English Cl poets. clu By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- 1960. list Published: (1969) The Arthur of the English SIXTY YEARS an poets, im By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- of 1960. OF THE Published: (1969) 18 The Arthur of the English UNION BOAT CLUB CO poets / se By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- 1960 Published: (1966) BY Mai The Arthur of the English poets / THE CLUB HISTORIAN By: Maynadier. Howard, 1866- F 1960. N Published: (1907) The wife of Bath's tale: its Lan sources and analogues, Pu By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- 1960. Published: (1901) The wife of Bath's tale: its sources and analogues. S By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- 1960 Published: (1972) The first American novelist? By: Maynadier, Howard, 1866- A LIST OF MEMBERS 1960. AND Published: (1940) The works of Henry Fielding THE MORE IMPORTANT RACES OF THE CLUB with the author's preface By: Fielding Henry. 1707-1754 FROM 1851 TO 1911 Published: (1918) P The works of Daniel Defoe / Des By: Defoe, Daniel, 1661?-1731. COMPILED BY Published: (1903) THE SECRETARY L Justa V Vie G. Mayradier Full Han BOSTON Added: 8/14/18 PRINTED FOR THE UNION BOAT CLUB R. Stanton Avery Special Collections Dept. New England Historic Genealogical Society 101 Newbury Street Boston, MA 02116 1871 - GBD & WWD go to London- then join parents at Baden-Baden (Good copy - to be read for typographical errors) Trace noute on map Italy. 1872-1874 - C.H.D. to Paris for winter, going to Riviera and &WWW to Rome; ChD. returned home in spring; GBD & WWD going again, the same spring to England, Scotland and Wales, with Mr. Dana as a companion on the trip; in the fall of 1873 WWD returned home, & CHD joined GBD for a winter in Paris and on Riviera, returning home in the spring of 1874. (Good copy, but change has to be made, as it is written incorrectly.) 1874 - 1878 -- Abroad - Rome, etc. (unfinished) 1878 - trip to Brittany ; trip to Spain, winter of 1877 to be added to the story. 1882 - Trip to Central Italy & Sicily - Rough Copy 1891-1892 - Trip to Palestine & Up Nile - Good Canoeing Trip to Moosehead Lake with Sam Warren - 1895 1902 - Trip with Geologists - Good 1903 - GBD & Vanderbilts - Good 1904 - To Sierras - Good 1907 - Last Trip Abroad Rough A trip through Virginia Staying at Biltmore Estes Park - (Col. Fordyce; "A Constant Incentive to Patriotic Citizenship": Historic Preservation in Progressive-Era Page 1 of 3 This site uses cookies to provide you with a better experience. X For information on our cookie policy, please visit this page. By continuing to use the site or closing this banner, you are agreeing to our terms of use. Have library access? Log in through your library Log in Register JSTOR Search Browse Tools About SupportLog in Register JOURNAL ARTICLE Note: "A Constant Incentive to Patriotic Citizenship": Historic Preservation in Charles EliotNation writes in 1889 Progressive-Era Massachusetts that "moreigneeded than a mere James M. Lindgren intellectual recognition "of the impor- The New England THE NEW ENGLAND tance of the past to defining individ- Quarterly QVARTERLY illan vel lives. "Our sentiments draw Vol. 64, No. 4 (Dec. 1991), pp. 594-608 lourishment from material things, (15 pages) from vigible memorials, from Published By: The familiar objects to which New England Quarterly, Inc. affections may cling." https://doi.org/10.2307/366189 https://www.jstor.org/stable/366189 Here referenced, pg. 601. Cite this Item Read and download Log in through your school or library Alternate access options For independent researchers Journal Information The New England Quarterly, founded in 1928, is best described by its subtitle, A Historical Review of New England Life and Letters. Through major essays, memoranda and edited documents, reconsiderations (of scholarly editions, influential interpretive texts, and https://www.jstor.org/stable/366189 4/26/2021